Tweets and document screenshots from inside the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry hearing room.
188 tweets
I'm at the Post Office Horizon IT inquiry to hear the second day of former Cartwright King barrister, Harry Bowyer. We're already underway.

You can watch it live (or on catch up) here.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=pE7mwEg3XgU
I was delayed by the need to iron some shirts (difficult with a broken wrist) and a last minute call from @BBCr4today who asked for my thoughts on the appointment of the new Post Office chair – last ten minutes here: www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m001yqr2
I'm going to pick up on Harry Bowyer's (HB) evidence from this morning. Seems a bluff sort of chap, happy to be frank where it suits and defend his position where he can. He's being questioned by Emma Price for the Inquiry, and then the Subpostmaster barristers get a go.

EP starts with a variation on the standard opening gambit to the remotely-watching Inquiry Chair, Sir Wyn Williams (SWW) – usually "Good morning, sir, can you see and hear us/me?" this morning was "Good morning, sir, are the picture and sound working as they should?"
They are.

We go straight to the Cartwright King sift review – the "marking their own homework" review of PO prosecutions, prompted by the CK's barrister Simon Clarke's response to the Second Sight (2S) interim report. Here's HB's take on it in his witness statement (WS)


EP wants to know why the 2S report was disclosed to Alison Henderson but not the Helen Rose report
HB can't recall why



EP takes him to another disclosure case – that of Kathleen Crane who only recently got her conviction quashed) where he says that because it's a pre Horizon Online case (ie pre 2010) there's "nothing to disclose"


EP asks if pre-2010 attracted any disclosure in the CK Sift Review
HB yes
EP brings up another case (Peter Huxam) in which he does give disclosure



EP wants to know why there was a different approach to Huxam and Crane
HB can't remember
EP should there have been a common view
HB maybe. at the time we thought we were doing it right. Brian Altman said we were – twice. I can see now there might be a problem.
EP raises HB's deletion of case-specific info from Gareth Jenkins (GJ) including that of Seema Misra. Was there any thought given to telling Seema that the expert witness in her case was discredited
HB not my review of her case, but if I had been asked I would think it should
EP were you aware SPMs were raising issues with Horizon (H) system
HB lists the criminal allegations against SPMs, says they didn't fit H bugs and 2S said there were no systemic problems. We now know there were lots of bugs
EP raises HB's central defence of CK in his WS

EP did you recognise when the CK review was set did you think there were concerns.
HB yes
EP was marking your own homework a problem
HB yes, but Brian Altman said it was okay and it was th fastest way of getting the job done
EP was Martin Smith from CK involved in talking to…
… the Scottish Crown Office and BTO the PO's Scottish prosecutors. Were you involved?
HB no
EP did CK get involved in the Scot and NI cases
HB don't know
EP raises an email chain…




… which has been raised by an MP about a deceased SPM via James Arbuthnot. The Post Office does its usual job of trying to minimise its response.
EP wants to know if the sole purpose of putting this to CK was so they could tell MPs it had been reviewed by an external barrister
HB has no recollection of this
EP wants to know more about the Scots and NI prosecution review policy, but HB has little recollection
EP raises an email chain which appears to suggest BTO was NOT given the (late 2013) Deloitte report into remote access




HB agrees
EP there is no mention of your "reaction of shock" to what Deloitte report said and you also say an expert report will give H a clean bill of health, why so sure
HB cos the 2S report found no systemic issues
[there is a ding dong about the word "bandwagon" when talking about PO cases (HB uses it twice in his case reviews) – EP clearly sees it as pejorative (as do I), HB pushes back and says that it's a neutral term]
EP did the importance of the PO as a client to CK influence you
HB yes – we were worried about our bosses at CK, and we did worry how they would respond when we told them they had to stop prosecuting
EP ends her questioning
Ed Henry KC (EH) for Subpostmasters
EH you weren't happy with GJ's independence so you decided to draft a pro-prosecution template for him?
HB no
EH you said this would give defences "a windmill to tilt at"

EH that means "attacking imaginary enemies or evils" – is that what you thought SPMs were doing
HB at the time we thought H was robust
EH so yes
HB no it was so they could look at what we had and ash qs, your question is unfair
EH no it's not. you use a phrase which displays…
… you over-confident approach to the issue
HB we disagree. the idea was to give them a chance to make something of it
EH we had nothing to suggest the H system had any faults to it

EH you referred to defence inquiries as a "fishing expedition" did that reflect your view about disclosure in relation to H?
HB some, certainly
EH and you refer to defence challenges falling away before a trial – were you taking a blinkered approach?
HB that comment hasn't aged well, but no.
EH takes him to the CK response to the Altman review of CK's work "we need to have an expert say the system is sound" – blinkered assumption?


EH "raw rumour"? "potential disclosability" of flaws? Surely any flaws MUST be disclosed
HB I think you're right
EH so were you trying to sugar the pill for your client?
HB no – clumsy English
EH a number of these issues which reached the mediation scheme contained complaints about PO investigators – you advised against disclosing investigator reports
HB yes
EH the fact Mrs Doran (Scottish case) was being charged on H data and they were acquitted – why was that not disclosed?
HB didn't think of it
EH takes him to some more of HB's advice

EH why did you say this?
HB because it should be considered in the context of each case
EH does your advice not reveal a jaundiced approach
HB no
EH brings up Kathleen Crane's case – his client raised H issues in her interview – how on earth did you come to think she shouldn't…
… get disclosure
HB I don't know
Chris Jacobs (CJ) – centre – for more Subpostmasters

CJ in July 2012 you said the PO and Fujitsu (F) were in a firefighting situation and could be severely damaged by any revelations about H
HB yes
CJ so you were saying don't do anything that makes a concession that H is robust
HB not an unwarranted one
CJ raises Altman's opinion on past PO prosecutions – should he be doing this
HB many pleas were guilty, we stopped the prosecutions because of GJ, not because we thought the system was unsafe

CJ takes him to a Bond Dickinson's email about Altman's remit – is that view right?
SWW intervenes – this is not an appropriate line for this witness

Tim Moloney KC starts asking qs for more Subpostmasters (right of pic – Neil Hudgell on the left)

TM asks about Gillian Howard who had her conviction quashed. She pleaded guilty, but complained about H, made calls to the helpline, no investigation of her claims at interview – basically a slam dunk Horizon case
HB agrees [HB did not advise disclosure on her case]
TM takes him to his advice

[So HB raised serious concerns but did not advise disclosure?!?!]
HB I think I got this particular advice badly wrong
TM says there should have been disclosure at the time and at the time of your review
HB repeats he got this badly wrong
TM was this not disclosed because it would cause the PO embarrassment
HB there might have been a subconscious bias, but I like to think I'm a straight-edged prosecutor
SWW did you ever release the 2S to report to someone who had pleaded guilty
HB yes – where they raised H as an issue, but I might have not done it in all when I should have done
Heather Oliver asks qs on behalf of Gareth Jenkins
HO did you not think it was imperative to ask how GJ was instructed to give evidence in court
HB I did not take the lead on this case
HO did you satisfy yourself how he was instructed
HB no

HO did you ask Jarnail Singh if GJ was properly instructed
HB no
HO did JS mention the H issues GJ told him about including the 200,000 system faults [!!!!]
HB No
HO that F maintained a KEL
HB no
HO did you ever speak to GJ
HB no
HO takes him to a doc – Rodric Williams note from disco with Martin Smith – highlights box that says GJ has not been properly instructed.


HB says he was not party to any discussion around the lack of proper instruction to GJ
Next up is Martin Smith (MS) from CK.

Julian Blake (JB) asking the questions

MS is a criminal solicitor. Started in defence as a duty solicitor and then started prosecuting. Rose to senior associate at CK and then left with Simon Clarke and Harry Bowyer to start their own firm.
JB raises a prosecution case which is being discontinued by the Post Office. Jarnail Singh (JS) writes to Smith to say Horizon integrity issues must not be mentioned.

JB what did you understand by the Business interest
MS there will always be a Business interest in a private prosecution
JB takes him to his advice about a Mr Elvin who had found a way of fiddling the H system



MS advises not to proceed with the prosecution because it would reveal weaknesses with the H system
JB is that in the public interest
MS no it's in the business interest
JB should you not have said that? did you get that confused?
MS possibly
JB did that happen a lot
MS it's possible
JB well you were involved
MS I can't recall
JB you don't need to recall. reflect.
MS it's possible
JB takes him to another advice of his



JB v much alleging probs with Horizon
MS yes
JB takes him to another email in which MS states H is working perfectly

This is the Dixon defence


JB does not ask a question on this but notes that H is being raised. Moves onto the Ishaq case and MS's letter calling it a "fishing expedition"

It's a Jarnail Singh email to Gareth Jenkins saying they've got one of their people, Helen Rose to write a report saying Horizon is robust to use in prosecutions

JB you knew there were challenged to H and you did not like making disclosure to defendents
MS we were told it was robust so I was reluctant to disclose if it did not meet the disclosure test
JB who told you H was robust
MS Jarnail Singh and others
JB takes him back to the Ishaq case – MS agrees he had significant responsibility in this case (eventually)
Case notes…

JB reliability of H system front and centre of defence
MS yes
We see more of this…


JB why did you call this a fishing expedition
MS I don't recall sending it. But I did.
We go to a pre-trial hearing attended by Sarah Porter for CK



MS agrees that the "our stance" that "Horizon works" is info she got from him
JB her responses include the word "database" being compiled – who is compiling this

MS Singh told me the PO were doing this on the bases of HB's advice
JB the response from Mr Ishaq's request to particularise the claim – is that a tactic to non-disclose
MS no I thought it was sensible – if you've lost your keys in a hotel, it might help to think about which…
… rooms you're thinking of.
JB takes him to a CK billing guide, in which he discusses the Ishaq case with Sarah Porter

Then a JS email we've seen before

Then the Helen Rose note referred to in JS's email – NOT the Helen Rose report into the Lepton branch which came up in the GLO and the inquiry previously.
MS says he didn't read this. Just accepted PO stance the H system was robust.

The HR note raises the Yetminster case – Tracey Merritt (who the PO took 18 months to drop her prosecution and told her and her daughter they were not allowed to talk for that time – something which, in terror, they obeyed, ruining their relationship until this year)

The Rose note includes a number of cases including the Misra case


The Rose note concludes:

JB asks if there is the forming of an attempt to get defendants to be more specific about their H allegations
MS not really. I didn't see this document at the time
JB takes MS to the spreadsheet accompanying the HR note



MS I knew it existed and it was meant to be a live document, but I didn't read it. I was reassured by Jarnail Singh's assertion that the H system was bullet-proof
JB you knew about the 2S investigation, you knew about the database and HR's note – wouldn't this be exactly what Mr Ishaq's team would be after
MS short answer is yes. When I read it in prep for this in Inquiry I was "quite horrified" – it's cases where the PO dare not…
… prosecute. There was a case where the SPM could demonstrate a loss and it was not prosecuted.
JB takes him back to the defence statement in the ishaq case and raises iii) which would include the database and the list
MS it's broader, but I took the view that unfounded or unsubstantiated allegations were not disclosable which is what I though that list was
MS I took the view it was a very wide request
JB why did you not look at the Rose report or database then?
MS because I thought they were unsubstantiated
JB how about checking
MS i didn't
JB is that a failing
MS yes – but no one told me there was a problem
JB no one else had a view of Mr Ishaq's case. Why wasn't 2S's review disclosed?
MS 2S had been instructed but I don't think there were any results – I went through this request with Steve Bradshaw
JB should you have told them that there was an independent firm looking at H
MS that was disclosed by Bradshaw
JB when
MS in 2013
JB this is 2012, when we're dealing with disclosure requests
JB raises a chaser sent by Mr Ishaq's solicitors in Oct 2012


… still looking for data disclosure. We go back to the billing notes

MS raises a quirk of the billing guide as it's a copy and paste from the case pars which just give a flavour…
JB do you recall of Nimesh Patel?
MS it could have been Jishan Patel
JB were there two Patel cases raising H issues?
MS possibly
JB takes him to RP's entry into the billing guide – so you were clear that there was another case running at the same time as the Ishaq case

MS yes so I was thinking we might have to disclose something from possibly the Jishan Patel case to Mr Ishaq
JB so only if GJ was addressing Horizon Online would it trigger your thoughts re Ishaq?
MS I was made aware of a single bug in the Legacy Horizon case…
… the Falkirk/Callander Sq bug but it happened a while back and to a different version of the system
JB did that not challenge the H robustness narrative
MS no, it was a single bug affecting a single branch
JB moves on
Another letter from Ishaq's solicitors about data disclosure from the PO being received three months late

JB takes him to the disclosure guide which MS agrees he is drafting a letter for Rachel Panter to send the defence

RP sends an email asking MS to look at her letter

JB looks at RP's letters before and after MS's. The RP first draft is on the right, RP's post MS draft is on the left

MS says he advised taking out the reference to a self-imposed deadline. Was still hopeful for a new defence statement with more particularised issues
JB so this was not a tactic to put the onus on Ishaq
MS i don't believe so. I can see how it looks. we were asking him to…
… particularise the issues. The judge in a hearing had put the ball in their court.
JB any reference for further evidence coming their way had been removed
MS it was about not creating a self-imposed deadline
JB but you took out the reference to further evidence completely
MS we didn't know what that evidence was going to be so we didn't know if it would meet the test to disclosure so referring to it seemed to me to be "a little daft"
[We have broken for lunch. I am broken for lunch. If you want to get my irregular newsletter about this scandal (at least twice a week atmo), then please consider signing up here www.postofficescandal.uk/donate/]
Or buy my book, which Amazon have appeared to drop to 99p on Kindle in their May Madness sale.
x.com/mkiceburnmarko/status/1785646300035158506
www.amazon.co.uk/Great-Post-Office-Scandal-multimillion-ebook/dp/B098GGKMW7/ref=pd_aw_sbs_m_sccl_1/260-5547028-2327259?pd_rd_w=TVyFr&content-id=amzn1.sym.01687754-8917-4c9b-819f-fd00a7dd614d&pf_rd_p=01687754-8917-4c9b-819f-fd00a7dd614d&pf_rd_r=6MYN6VCMZE9PZAYCNPKN&pd_rd_wg=PV1NM&pd_rd_r=7d7c51b1-c5b3-4fcc-a36d-b4bbc05fee10&pd_rd_i=B098GGKMW7&psc=1
For anyone who wants to buy @nickwallis book about Post Office Scandal for 99p in relation to #PostOfficeScandal
#MrBatesPBS
#MrBates
If you buy my book from the publisher (for significantly more than 99p) you also get an invite to join the newsletter massive.
bathpublishing.com
We are back after lunch. Martin Smith's evidence continues #PostOfficeInquiry

We return to the back and forth between CK and Ishaq's solicitors about disclosure.
Ishaq's solicitors' letter


Internal thoughts email at CK

Agrees "grumbling" is not a fair description. They are looking for disclosure and not getting it. Also agrees there was no order to re-do the defence.
Julian Blake (JB) asks that given he was aware of the 2S review and although he had not read the Rose note or spreadsheet he was aware of them, then he showed a remarkable lack of curiosity
MS no. requests were too wide
JB takes him to a note from MS to Steve Bradshaw. Wants to know why MS was suspicious.


MS I thought we were being ambushed.
JB you say you're not giving disclosure in that email. You did not read the Rose table, why not do some basic research
MS I thought they were unsuccessful challenges
JB Khayyam Ishaq was given 54 weeks imprisonment after pleading guilty. Before sentencing we see this email from
… Jarnail Singh asking about advice on staying prosecutions.
MS Thinks it was a request for general advice. "Mr Singh wasn't always that easy to understand with the way he phrased things or discussed things"

MS Mr Singh wasn't always the easiest to decipher
JB why
MS because his emails were unclear
JB did he have a nefarious purpose
MS I thought at the time was the language used but as this rolled on I think it's because he knew more than he was letting on
JB what do you think was going through his mind
MS that there were perhaps more things he knew that we didn't know and that informed his response
JB takes him to the MS response to JS advising against staying cases

MS this was CK's view
JB it says "my view" – was it your view
MS yes, after discussing internally
[BTW Fiona Parker from the @Telegraph is live-blogging alongside me with actual quotes and everything www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/05/01/post-office-inquiry-live-horizon/]
@Telegraph JB highlights this par – you're putting the burden on the defendants to raise an issue which might satisfy some sort of test rather than being open and honest
MS no this is taking it as a case-by-case approach. Some had made admissions. Some said H wasn't relevant

@Telegraph JB how would you test for a ""real" issue"?
MS I don't think I considered that point
JB brings up the Helen Rose report into the Lepton branch. can you remember when you saw this?
MS it was at a meeting at PO HQ in Old Street
JB you say you discussed the 2S report on 27 June – was it then?
MS that's when I got a call from someone in PO legal asking me about bugs

… in H in a way that suggested they had no idea about bugs in H. I called Singh who also indicated he had no idea about bugs in H… [he is not sure]
JB let\s stick with the HR report – who alerted you to it?
MS no idea
JB when JS said he knew nothing about bugs, did you…
… query it?
MS no as I was taken by surprise too. I thought PO legal, like us, did not know about bugs
JB goes to HR report mentioning "H itegrity issues" and problems when prosecuting

JB raises transcript of a call between Simon Clarke (SC) and MS and Gareth Jenkins (GJ). How did this come about
MS yes SC was concerned about a prosecution we were undertaking as we wanted to know if the 2S report would be disclosed
JB this is 28 June, day after call from…
… PO about bugs and your chat with JS
MS yes
JB did know this was being recorded or typed up or what?
MS I am not sure if I was recording it or typed it
JB presumably GJ did not know it was being recorded
MS no

More…


More…

More…

More…
JB raises the "functioning perfectly" line
MS cannot explain what that is

More…. [this was a very short call]


JB did you have concerns about H integrity at that point
MS SC certainly did and we'd had a discussion about that, so yes there was a concern within CK about GJ
JB in the Ishaq case, GJ gave two statements. GJ mentioned "you can never say no more bugs" – personal concerns?
MS Yes. I raised this with SC and said GJ did not raise these issues. But in court GJ stated in court there were no bugs affecting his branch. Now we were being told about two bugs by GJ. I told SC about the case and that KI pleaded guilty. SC said that didn't matter…
… those bugs should have been disclosed.
JB did you realise there was now a problem with GJ
MS yes
JB was that disclosed to the ongoing criminal cases
MS Simon Clarke and Susan Crichton decided to put a moratorium on all cases
JB what about Ishaq
MS I remember feeling…
… quite angry and I asked SC to review the case. Which he did the next day.
JB why didn't you review the case
MS I though it was better to get a senior barrister to do it.
JB goes to an email written by JS to his colleagues


MS says this email materially represents his and SC's conversation with GJ
JB it doesn't suggest GJ's unreliability and more bugs in the system
MS I don;t follow his speculation line – I don't know where he's got that from
JB did you tell JS what GJ told you and your concerns…
… about GJ.
MS I can't recall what I said to JS
JB highlights this par – why mention it to the judge in private

MS I was entirely in SC's hands here and he said this was the best way forward
SWW in private ie not in public, but with the legal representatives present
MS no in private – I went with SC to the judge's chambers to tell him about this report which we hadn't seen
SWW I see
JB why not mention it in open court?
MS you'll have to ask SC – I had done defence work all my career and was new to this and this was what SC said to do
JB you'd been working for CK for six years by this stage
MS we had no training on prosecutions and it was felt that…
… it would be better for the PO if senior counsel took the lead on this.
JB one reading of this is that its best to do it in private because it's better for the PO
MS no, and actually when we were reviewed Brian Altman made clear he wouldn't have dropped the case
JB takes him to v18a of the 2S Interim Report covering email from Hugh Flemington and sent to MS on 4 July




JB is scrolling through it…

JB brings in the MS response email to getting the report

JB adverse publicity?
JB are you confusing the PO's private interests and legal requirements
MS no it's a concern about a partial report
JB why is publicity a concern in criminal prosecutions
MS this followed a Post Office meeting and they were concerned about adverse publicity
JB not need to disclose the report in every case
MS that was where we were at the time in our thinking
JB strong line given what you knew
MS given the CK sift review we only disclosed them in some of the cases
JB yes we're coming to that – JB shows him the second half of…
… the 2S report including the spot reviews. Which CK got an hour later. This is the covering email chain


JB says on 10 July CK propose sending a letter to Khyyan Ishaq's solicitors
MS I was so concerned about the case I wanted to do something immediately, rather than wait for the sift review

JB he was sent to prison in April, this is the letter sent in July

P2 of the proposed letter
JB no apology in this letter
MS correct
JB no admission of wrongdoing
MS correct – letter is as you've read it
JB and no sharing allowed
MS I didn't consider that point. It's SC's letter.

JB no reference to reliability of GJ
MS no
JB no list of H concerns prepped by HR in 2012
MS no
JB why was the 2S report and the HR report considered sufficient
MS I hadn't read the HR note or spreadsheet and this is what we had been provided with
JB why no GJ
MS don't know
JB takes us to an email from Rodric Williams about the HR report
JB what did you make of the PO's attitude to openness
MS my impression was they were content to follow SC's advice

JB takes MS to a email he wrote Rodric Williams about privilege



It ends.
JB why are you trying to narrow the circs in which this report could be disclosed
MS I was taking advice from SC
JB does that make it any less troubling
MS I was deferring to our senior in house barrister

JB so you are getting quite concerned about how candid the PO is being
MS well the HR report has arrived and its in addition to the 2S interim report so there is another report to deal with. I dont think I gave it much more thought. SC went on to redact the HR report…
… and SC drafted the letter to be sent out to the intended recipients
JB you say in your WS you weren't aware of the post-conviction duty of disclosure
MS I became aware of it by discussing KI's case
JB is that not a concern
MS i didn't at the time
JB now
MS yes
SWW you took the view that the 2S report and the HR report should be disclosed, but there was no discussion about GJ – aren't they inextricably linked?
MS no discussion about him
SWW yes that's the surprise
MS there was literally no discussion about GJ and when we went to…
… see Brian Altman about this there was again no discussion about whether we should explain the GJ issue to the people we were sending letters to.
SWW I am sure that will be taken up
BREAK
We're back and we're about to discuss the Criminal Cases Review Commission's (CCRC) involvement after the 2S Interim Report (IR) in 2013.
The CCRC are on the front foot


JB do you recall being asked to draft a response
MS it would appear we were but I don't recall it

Simon Clarke writes a response.
JB was this vounteered or did Susan Crichton (SCPO) ask you to draft it

MS I guess this was a response to a request from the PO legal dept, but I didn't have much to do with it

JB reads out draft reply

It goes on. JB picks up the onus on the prosecution to demonstrate the integrity of H


JB is that what the PO did?
MS [waffles but I think he says no]
JB continues to read out the par referring to GJ, but it has no reference to GJ's reliability
MS agrees
JB says the first Clarke Advice was produced the next day – surprising it does not mention the concerns of the Clarke Advice
MS yes, it should have

JB you've also mentioned 2SIR, but not the HR report
MS agrees
JB notes the phrase "independent firm of criminal specialists" – who is that?
MS CK
JB are they independent given they prosecuted the cases
MS we were independent of PO
… but we weren't independent of the prosecutions because we'd conducted a number of them
JB reads on

JB no mention of anything other than the 2SIR – correct?
MS correct – not sure the letters had gone out at this stage
JB reads on… thus far no reviews sought…
next page… reads final par. Is this an accurate reflection of the PO's attitude?

MS in my mind there was very little known. The 2SIR and the HR report.
JB did you read this?
MS not sure
JB you just forward stuff. this is to the CCRC
MS if SC wrote this I'd trust him and forward it
[this is a terrible, terrible admission]
JB is this letter not a concern?
MS it seems I just forwarded documents
JB so on 16 July you were forwarding docs to CCRC, then on 19 July you're in a meeting about H problems

JB no minutes circulated… remember this?
MS I recall one of the civil lawyers from BD (later WBD) he was talking from a disclosure position in civil litigation and notes on email could be forwarded for good reason…

… and circulated and end up where they should be. [MS says it was Andy Parsons who advised this]
MS says from a crim perspective we had advised on a central hub for a similar reason
JB what are you saying here about disclosability of docs
MS I don't think this is accurate. AP said we needed to limit circulation of docs. I said any info should be accurate and kept
JB takes him to APs comments

Which are…


JB what's going on here
MS this is AP talking about his experience as a civil lawyer and the nasty surprises he's had in the past
JB what about the need to limit public debate about Horizon
MS I do not recall the meeting. I made notes I left at CK. I think it was about…
… good document control.
JB need to limit public debate
MS don't recall that
JB no circulation of minues – that's a worry
MS it would have been if AP had not explained his rationale
JB taking a step back – there's a lot going on at the time
JB lists the issues 2SIR, HR report, chat with GJ, letter to CCRC which does not mention GJ and now there's a discussion about limiting info in public domain
MS no. cos the rationale was explained – keeping a central hub
JB so the purpose of the central store was to…
… stop it being distributed.
MS no it was to keep the info in one place
MS the minute you get to email chains being circulated is the minute you don't have full visibility of the issues which might need to be recorded
JB takes MS to document retention and destruction post-19 July
JB telephone call with John Scott?
MS no this is a note of a conversation with Jarnail Singh.

MS there was more to this call as it was 24 minutes long
JB what do you recall of this discussion
MS I've put this in both WS – I was actually driving when I took the call from Singh. I recall complaining to him about the influence being exerted over PO by the external civil…
… lawyers and I recall him telling me that an instruction had been sent out that the typed minutes would be scrapped and if anyone would be asked CK would be blamed for sending that instruction out.
MS I can recall being "absolutely horrified and shocked by what I'd heard" and when I pulled over I used another mobile phone to record the latter part of the conversation because I was just "so shocked by what I heard". I can recall relaying that to Mr Clarke – I am afraid…
… I can't recall much more but I remember relaying it to Mr Clarke about Singh's comments. This was about a fortnight since the first meeting and a day after the second. I remember saying to him I appreciate the need for a central hub…
… but I recall by the third call there was some kind of change proposed – no hold on you still need to keep a central record and remember I was going to ask SC to prepare an Advice [the Shredding Advice] that would put this in B&W
… in my mind I thought it was the civil lawyers trying to "water it down" and move away from the situation. I thought the PO had accepted our view and were acting in good faith rightly or wrongly and to get to the position by the third meeting…
… that nothing was going to be written down that really did worry me. We'd gone from a situation where we had minutes being kept on a spreadsheet or a central hub to one where no minutes were going to be kept at all…
JB the words here were scrapped. Now did that mean stopped or destroyed
MS destroyed
JB that was your clear understanding of that call from Jarnail Singh
MS yes
JB SC in his advice uses the word "shredded" now did that arise out of your conversation with Singh
MS yes
JB do you recall that word being used in the conversation with Singh
MS not now no
JB but you clearly understood typed minutes were to be destroyed
MS yes
JB were to be or had been destroyed
MS under. the impression the instruction had gone out and they had been destroyed
JB instruction from who to whom?
MS John Scott sent it out – I believe it went to David Pardoe or David Posnett
JB was John Scott acting on advice?
MS no idea – I was just concerned that by the time we reached the third meeting something had changed, and I was left with the distinct impression that Post Office no longer wanted the meeting recorded and I told them it needed to be on a central record
JB who at the Post Office
MS can't and he no longer has his notes from that meeting.
JB takes him to one more doc…

JB what's Singh saying here?
MS I'd already told him we needed things kept in writing
JB common myth
MS no idea what that means – I'd already pointed out to him that records must be kept
[evidence for the day ends. Chris Aujard back first tomorrow then MS will continue]
Well, well, well… some drama – a lawyer getting a call from the Post Office saying the Post Office is shredding documents and not keeping records, the lawyer pulling his car over so he can try to record the call on another device (no word of what happened to that yet)… and…
…. some confusion on who ordered the shredding order, issued (or generated?) by Head of Security John Scott.
Was it relayed by Rodric Williams, issued by Rodric Williams, issued on advice from Bond Dickinson, or as John Scott seemed to suggest, Susan Crichton.
Most people so far seem to be pointing at John Scott, who absolutely denies it.
More on this, no doubt, tomorrow and when Jarnail Singh gives evidence on Friday.
Right, I;m off home. Thanks for reading.
Wrote up that key evidence at the end, here:
www.postofficescandal.uk/post/martin-smith-and-the-instruction-to-shred/
#PostOfficeScandal

