Live tweets from Day 171 of the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry.
173 tweets
Good morning and welcome to day 171 of the Post Office Inquiry. Sir Vince Cable and Greg Clark – two former Biz Secretaries giving evidence today. Cable first. Here's his welcome committee outside Aldwych House.

I'm joined on the press bench by Adam and Emily from BBC Online. The hearing room is slightly less sparse than it was yesterday for Margot James. This is my report on her evidence – she spoke about the PO being great at playing the victim in this scandal.
www.postofficescandal.uk/post/the-wine-gums-vs-the-blob/
I'll be live tweeting Vince Cable (VC)'s evidence. Not sure about Clark. See how it goes…
The Inquiry's summer hearings finish on Tuesday next week. I've heard from a few people (nothing official yet) that the Inquiry won't restart till mid September and could go on till…
… mid-November. Not sure at this stage whether I'll be able to cover that.
But let's focus on the here and now. VC has been sworn in…

Jason Beer KC (JB) is asking the questions

VC has confirmed he was the business sec in the business department – then called BIS – now DBT – for the duration of the coalition govt (2010 to 2015) and that he had four Postal Affairs ministers.
JB was that unusual
VC does not answer the question
JB was the churn a problem
VC no – I was unusual in getting 5 years in office. In Jo Swinson's case she had mat leave, that wasn't churn. There was a mixing up of our portfolio
JB was the brief of Postal Affairs minister too broad?
VC there was a lot to do. I had 100 items in…
… my portfolio. The PO was part of a junior minister's portfolio and that was fine.
JB did any junior minister raise capacity as an issue
VC no
NB nothing I tweet is a direct quote unless it is in "direct quotes" – it is a characterisation and/or summary of what is being said
JB your ministerial diary and minutes of meetings have not been retained. Neither was Swinson's or Ed Davey – why
VC no idea – had a meeting with Paula Vennells (PV) and Alice Perkins (AP) from the PO – that was not recorded. Andrew Bridgen came to see me about PO cases – no…
… record of that either.
JB did you ask why?
VC yes and no one knows. Might have been transfer from paper to digital
JB you say probs with Horizon IT system (H) never came across your desk – correct?
VC yes
JB this was a crucial period. Threat of a class action, discovery of evidence which cast doubt on safety of convictions, CCRC started an investigation. Second Sight had been instructed (JB mentions their FOUR reports I think for the first time) – see my post on Margot James…
… above for more detail on that.
JB why did you not get this info
VC officials underestimated how big this is. I was not told. I knew nothing of Computer Weekly's work. Should have been told about Alan Bates – never heard his name in 5 years.
VC this probly came down to civil servants thinking I didn't need to be
JB you say govts across the spectrum share responsibilty for this and you share responsibility
VC yes – this was a state enterprise and it happened on our watch
JB what specifically did you do wrong
VC general oversight of the department. No specific interventions I made or was asked to make that would change anything
JB takes VC to his Witness Statement (WS) par 33

JB contrasts this with par 13

Then to par 92

VC I had raised a debate in parliament about the way SPMs were treated by the PO. A woman in my constituency invested £75,000 – £100,000 in her PO. It was taken away. Another was opened up nearby. Not explained properly to me. So I had a debate and heard from other MPs
… I took all this to the PO and they brushed it aside and called me an interfering MP. This happened when I was in gov. A man from the Federation came to me with 50 to 100 cases in a scrapbook to illustrate what was being done to SPMs, but he didn't mention the IT system
… but it seemed like the PO had a "one strike and you're out policy" – and people could lose their POs for a single mistake. I did get help from the Federation – Mr [Colin] Baker worked with me to get compensation for one member and after that I had a good view of the NFSP
JB you mention Mr Bates description of "thugs in suits" as something you recognise – why
VC the way they operated. When I raised issues with them the attitude came across to me as it was described to you
JB so it was from meeting them face to face
VC yes and their attitude in correspondence
JB when did you become aware of SPMs challenging the PO over their enforcement attitude
VC I wasn't until after Andrew Bridgen came to me – I asked the Postal minister what was going on and that's when I found out about Second Sight
JB when did you become aware of PO privately prosecuting people
VC was never aware of it
JB in your period in office?
VC right at the end when James Arbuthnot (JA) had his q in parly and there was a select committee I started asking qs and found out then
JB what about SPMs being prosecuted on potentially unreliable H data
VC at the end again
JB goes to par 40 of VC's WS

JB skips over the quoted section to par 41

… which ends:

JB takes him to the letter referred to in the above pars

More…

Ends…

JB would you read letters before sending them
VC yes, but in August I was sent abroad to sign trade deals and had a short break with my wife. Several hundred letters and emails would come in a day and they would mostly get dealt with by my staff….
… They might come to me – Miliband was a privy counsellor. This was a standard letter. It was the departmental line. It was routine correspondence.
JB what inquiries would you expect to be undertaken what is said in the letters sent.
VC when I first came into office I would expect to have been told there were questions being raised about H by Computer Weekly and JFSA – I wasn't. I was told this was an issue that wasn't…
… controversial. I was v reliant as we all were on the competence and integrity of the people giving us advice.
JB what investigation would you expect your officials to do to be able to put together a letter like this?
VC to consult someone independent to validate this claim…
… and speak to the people making these criticisms of the H system.
JB was it sufficient to have lines provided to them by PO and simply incorporated those into your or your ministers' letters without testing
VC they should have done some challenge or investigation
JB in par 31 of your WS… [reads it out]

And the third here.. to give SPMs more power
JB why did you think there was an imbalance
VC from my own experience of seeing how they were dealt with and a broader policy issue re the PO's "monopsony"

VC I thought at the outset we needed to change this – Ed Davey felt in discos with the Fed to create a mutual structure to put SPMs in charge of the PO. This never came off, unfortunately.
JB takes him to a letter from Yasmin Qureshi MP

Notes problem with the IT system…

Asks VC to read on…

JB would you have seen this type of letter
VC never saw this – it would go to the correspondence unit – send to the dept and the answer would come back through a civil servant or the Postal Minister.
JB you wanted to address the imbalance in the relationship between SPMs and PO – this letter speaks directly to that issue
VC yes – the proposal I put to parly 10 years earlier was that there needed to be an arbitration mediation mechanism – when I spoke to Ed Davey and the Fed..
… that's how the idea of mutualisation came up. We probably should have been more modest and put SPMs on the PO board which has now happened.
JB why was corr which spoke to imbalance of power not flagged to you
VC I had a vast portfolio – this was 1 – 2% of my workload…
… and they judged the Postal minister or whoever would deal with it on my behalf.
JB let's look at some of those junior minister responses…
[letter from ed davey to Norman Lamb MP]

JB So Ed Davey is responding to a letter to VC from NL re Allison Henderson
VC yep – when I came into govt I got complaints that MPs were not even getting responses so I beefed up the corr dept – the messages in the letter are consistent with what I'd heard
… eg ops matter, legal issues, can't get involved with ops matters or legal issues etc
JB the second par says issues raised in NL's letter are ops matters.

JB points out that the assertion no issues with H were raised in court is false. We know that now. For this corr what kind of inquiry would you expect officials to make before including information like this
VC to interrogate the PO's position and if they were satisfied to put this in a letter
JB this has a dig at AH – what work would you expect the officials to do before putting this in a letter
VC this is a level of detail I can't make a useful comment on. it was incumbent…
… on the dept to investigate, but its not unreasonable for them to repeat what the PO said.
JB so it's fine for them to cut that detail into the letter
VC it is a little odd now you mention it but I can't make an intelligent comment on it
JB I know you weren't…
… involved, but did you know about the process about that went into finding out the info and testing it.
VC imagine the civil servants in BIS asked the PO about this case and they got the info and had to trust the reply they were given
JB takes VC to a letter from Ed Davey (ED) to Glenda Jackson MP

… re H problems

JB were you familiar with this line
VC yes I heard it in parly – re the PO's responsibility for ops matters. When I met PV for the first time she explained this division of labour again.
JB what did you understand the law as to ops independence mean?
VC I had strategic overview, financing etc and the PO could do the ops – opening and closing of POs etc
JB lists three letters in to VC raising H issues and action taken against SPMs – would you expect anyone in your office to draw together correspondence complaining about the same thing
VC I'd expect the operational civil servant to be aware of a systemic problem if there was one
VC I didn't want to be caught in a Sir Humphrey situation so I was blindsided by officials with a biased view so I set up…
JB what's a Sir H situation –
VC officials might have a different view to me – so I set up meetings with MPs to hear their view. in 5 years…
… only Andrew Bridgen came to see me and he brought an NFSP official who didn't raise Horizon. Surprised no one else came to see me.
JB when did you find out about the MP group led by James Arbuthnot
VC only in March 2015
JB why?
VC I guess they trusted the Post Office minister – they could have stopped me at any time – I walked past them in parly several times a day
JB so JA wasn't concerned?
VC no he did a monumental amount of work, but obviously chose to do it in other ways
JB you're not being critical of those MPs
VC no JA did a heroic job I wouldn't dare criticise him
JB this boilerplate response and sticking to it – means there's no investigation
VC there should have been an investigation, but once done there needs to be a consistent response
JB goes to the Second Sight (2S) investigations – take VC to his WS

JB you say you weren't aware of the publication of the 2S interim report, when did you become aware of it…
VC never given a formal detailed brief on the work of 2S. Only heard after the AB and NFSP visit and I asked the minister what was going on
VC even then I wasn't told it was an IT investigation I was told it was a general investigation.
VC when I asked the minister – think it was Jo Swinson – what we're doing about this – that's what she told me
JB was this first period of her office?
VC probably
JB takes him back to his unsigned letter re Kevin Carter in Aug 2012 which notes the Second Sight investigation
VC I had no knowledge of this and never saw it

JB takes him to a letter from VC's private office in July 2013

JB takes VC to that news story attached to the email – it is a Private Eye article

[this what I wrote about the same report at the time – becarefulwhatyouwishfornickwallis.blogspot.com/2013/08/post-office-2nd-sight-report-into.html]
JB so it seems you'd read this piece
VC well I'd seen it
JB what's the difference between seeing and reading
VC skimmed it and the headline – glanced at this – saw the brutal way about the PO
JB only glanced at it? sure?
VC yes wasn't an important part of a day's routine…
… here was someone who had been a critic of the PO praising the gov and PO so I thought this is good and then the dept dampened my enthusiasm
JB "raft of failings" "brutal" "unfair business model" – why think this was a good news story
VC I picked up on the fact JA applauded the PO and its open way of allowing its flaws to be exposed – saw that someone was saying something positive about the dept – most coverage is…
… negative. So I suggested the press office take this further.
JB takes him back to the reply to the email by his private office

reads it to the end
JB so pours cold water on your idea – what happened next
VC can't remember
JB why didn't you ask to see the report – there's clearly a big diff of opinion
VC saw it as a minor PR win, was warned off it as I often was
JB would you have expected to see the…
… report.
VC no – Swinson was handling it well
JB would you expect an impartial brief on the report
VC not really – this was a v small part of my portfolio I left it to my office and colleagues to bring me what they felt was important and they didn't
JB you saw the PE article and saw it as an issue of substance
VC saw the PE article – didn't recognise it was a matter of substance
JB why not
VC only spent a few seconds on it
JB so that's why you saw it as good news, rather than everything in it which points in the opposite…
… direction.
VC yes
[we take a break]
[we're back]
JB you tell us in your WS about letters from JA and Mr Bailey MP – let's look at them
JB this from JA to you March 2015

… reads body of the letter

JB goes to letter in from Bailey – quite bad quality. JB reads it out…

JB you say you replied to the letters, the draft of the responses and you did not agree to their advice not to read your response before signing
VC I wasn't happy with the draft response. Stylistically we needed to be more respectful and the substance…
… of the letter entirely hinged on accepting the view of the PO. I said have we asked the SPMs if they're happy, so I declined to sign the letter until I'd been given evidence on that point.
JB a number of the earlier letters that had gone entirely depended on the PO view. – what's the difference
VC what happened here was that I realised there was something "really rather important and bad going on" – this was the select committee and a senior MP – so I needed…
… to think about this. I was in the middle of the last big crisis of my time – I had to decide whether or not to ban weapons exports to Saudi and I had to take time out to think about whether or not to sign this letter.
JB takes him to the version he did sign

JB takes him to the end of the letter

JB that "there is no evidence… two years of investigation" was that a suggestion put to you by officials
VC yes but as I was confronting this for the first time I wanted officials to check with the NFSP that this was their understanding and the GS had appeared before the…
… select committee and said there wasn't a problem, so it seemed to me to be reasonable to accept that collective view.
JB so the critical turning point was the GS of the NFSP –
VC yes
JB George Thomson?
VC yes
JB did he strike you as a tool
[pause]
… a tool of the PO?
VC no reason to doubt their integrity
JB should you not have included sentences from 2S's report
VC maybe – we were under pressure – even when given reassurance about the NFSP's view I still didn't sign it – I was starting to smell a rat. And had I been returned to office…
… I would have got them ALL round the table, Bates, NFSP, JA, BIS, PO et al and thrashed it out. I didn't.
JB takes him to the response to Adrian Bailey MP (who I think was chair of the select committee)
Here it is…

More

JB is that what you understood you were being asked to do – influence the outcome?
VC no I was pleased there was a mediation process I suggested 15 years earlier – the fact it hadn't gone well wasn't good
JB keeps reading about lack of systemic issues..
… number of users etc
JB that small number of cases vs number of users and transactions – was that put to you by officials as an important point
VC yes I am sure it was – we don't understand why an IT system can work most of the time with catatstrophic consequences when…
… it doesn't
JB did anyone explain it
VC no
JB did you ask
VC no
JB the inquiry understands code regression, and interaction of circs which leads to undesirable outcomes
VC would have helped if someone in gov explained that to me at the time.
JB goes to a briefing note copy and paste of a Computer Weekly article

JB agree that 140 MPs with outstanding cases is sig
VC yes it's appalling
JB was JA's statement that you'd listened to the PO and not sought to understand etc etc accurate
VC no – I only agreed to support official line when I heard the NFSP were content
[I've written before about the NFSP's complicity in this scandal – utterly shameful www.postofficetrial.com/2019/12/nfsp-attempts-reverse-ferret.html]
VC what is weird is that none of the 140 MPs ever came to see me about it.
JB Adrian Bailey wrote you a detailed letter was that not enough
VC no – they should have come to see me face to face
JB so you do blame them
VC not at all I have enormous respect for them
… but it is unfortunate none of them came to see me or buttonholed me
JB would the outcome be different if they did
VC I think so
JB would you not have got exactly the same lines from officials
VC possibly, but I would have been more alert to the parly challenge
JB takes VC to par 79 of his WS and reads it out

JB takes him to the corr behind this statement

… continues… [nice to get a mention]

JB did you see this
VC no – this was also the end of parly and I was dealing with Saudi Arabia issue
JB would anything be done to alert the new Sec of State as to issues not being addressed.
VC I was hoping I would be the new SoS and I would have a chance to deal with it
VC the rational thing to do would be for the new SoS to get everyone together as I realised there was a big problem – part of my role as SoS was convening and I would have dealt with the matter in that way
JB you say the PO board was a failure – wish you'd thought more about the board and whether it was doing its job properly.
JB tell us more
VC we knew bad things were happening at the PO and the board was where members would have surfaced this and reported it back to gov. that didn't happen. I wanted to give SPMs a bigger voice and an easier way of doing it was to ensure SPMs were on the board.
… didn't occur to me at the time. Wish it had.
JB you also say you didn't spot ther was something wrong with Alice Perkins (PO Chair) and Paula Vennells (PO CEO) attending meetings together – how so?
VC I now know about separation of roles of CEO and Chair – didn't appreciate this at the time. With AP and PV they were a double act – and when they met me on a couple of occasions, they were together. They needed to be more separate.
JB concerns about competency of PO senior management
VC no – when I first met PV I said I didn't think much of PO management and asked her to read my Hansard report, but she had nothing to do with it. She didn't seem a problem.
JB were you ever told that PO board and ShEx had concerns about her abilities?
VC no never
JB didn't what you see cause you concerns
VC no I wasn't aware that early and when it did come up I got reassurance from the NFSP
VC I did ask my officials to look at whether this 1% prosecution rates was normal in franchise ops and they came back and told me it was
JB reads VC's reflections in his WS

JB can you expand on this
VC not really – there was a mediation scheme and it didn't work – the details were wrong. It can work if the details are right
JB what about point 2
VC we should be looking at those models and apply it in the case of the PO
Sir Wyn Williams (inquiry chair SWW) – re point 1 – the 2013 mediation scheme – does your phrase independent regulator/arbitrator mean there should be a body which imposes a solution on parties whether they like it or not
VC exactly that
JB takes him to point 3 and reads it out
JB do you mean legally responsible through legislation
VC yes – attracted to this idea because the Perm Sec in BIS was legally responsible to parly – real accountability

… there are analogous systems in the private sector. We need someone legally responsible for the tech and a line of accountability. Or depts can fall over.
JB takes him to point 4 – primary duty is to protect wider public interest

JB is that established already – was that the members' duty
VC implicit
JB how
VC there was a gov rep on the board, but he or she was looking out for taxpayers' money, but the other public obligations inc welfare of SPMs was not being addressed. We probly hadn't thought…
… through how exactly this would be done.
JB so Mr Callard's duty was to protect the wider public interest rather than to hold and discharge the duties of any other board member
VC yes he was there to discharge the public interest via gov
JB was that obvious at the time?
VC prob not
JB you say this (point 4) requires a specific structure which would have to be legislated for – do you have this in mind for all public corps
VC well I don't want to redesign govt… and these are all v different animals
JB takes him to 5)

which ends…
JB what's an explicit mandate?

VC it's about where you draw the line between ops and strategy – avoiding micromanaging from the centre. But this needs a mechanism when things go badly wrong for ministers to interfere. Schools and hospitals have that mechanism, but there isn't that with the PO
JB so special measures?
VC yes
[we have a break – that's the end of JB's qs – there are going to be 45 mins of questions from core participants to the inquiry taking us up to lunch]
A former Postal Affairs minister writes…
x.com/scullyp/status/1816421655389884855
Interesting lack of connection between SoS Vince Cable and his junior minister. When I was postal affairs minister we started every day with a 20 min max meeting between Perm Secs & all ministers so we all played 'total football' – a top level overview of the issues.
[we're back]
JB aplogises – there is one more area he wants to look at before CPs have a go
JB takes VC to par 90 of his WS
JB reads from 5 lines from the bottom – re being lied to

and in par 110 "lied to"
JB is there a distinction between being lied to and misinforming
VC yes
JB what's the basis for the assertion that ShEx officials were lied to by the PO
VC nothing specific – this has come from what I've seen of the Inquiry

JB any individual in ShEx do you think was lied to by the PO
VC can't do that – we had 3 to 4,000 civil servants and no idea which individuals in ShEx related to whom in the PO
Angela Patrick (AP) now asking qs on behalf of SPMs. Jo Hamilton is sitting on her right

AP brings up VC's WS par 118 and gov IT disasters "no information indicating this one didn't or wouldn't work"

AP you were aware of multiple diff IT failures
VC yes
AP and you knew that IT had risk esp with public bodies
VC not just public bodies
AP okay – but this had cost taxpayer dearly
VC yes
AP complete disasters that didn't do what they were supposed to do
VC yes
AP you say you had scepticism
VC yes
AP would you expect others to have this scepticism
VC yes – and there was a lot around H but by the time I got to govt they'd had 10 years to work out the problems and I had no reason to believe it wasn't working okay
AP so the historic risk about IT didn't go away with the forming of the coalition
VC no
AP so if I mention Fujitsu's Libra system in the courts – criticised in 2011 in the mainstream media
VC don't remember that
AP if there was a contractor contracting across diff depts…
… was there a mechanism for sharing info?
VC don't think so. we had IT systems break down in our dept and when I asked why I was told that it was my fault as I'd ordered that IT contracts should go to smaller operators and they didn't have the capacity to fix them so the…
… decision had to be reversed.
AP we're talking at cross-purposes – is there a mechanism for sharing intel between depts about IT issues
VC cabinet office co-ords all this
AP [changes subject] if you had been aware of probs in gestation of H or with projects made by Fujitsu…
… would that have increased or decreased your scepticism
VC the 2013 case I thought was a PR issue. in 2015 I realised there was a systemic problem… don't remember Fujitsu being mentioned but there was clearly an issue with them
AP if you or the dept or ShEx had awareness…
… of issues with the early stages of H that would increase scepticism.
VC yes, but it was rolled out in 1999 – would expect by 2010 it was sorted
AP any convo about Fujitsu at all re Horizon?
VC no – all F convos were about developing industrial strategy
AP we know the campaign by SPMs was running before you became SoS in 2010. Did any of your officials mention F were involved in concerns around H issues
VC no
AP would you expect that to be raised with you
VC would expect a briefing in 2010 about qs about H being raised by…
… serious people, but they weren't.
[AP finishes Flora Page (FP) picks up for more SPMs]
FP want to talk about strategy – separate RMG from PO to privatise RMG and mutualise the PO
FP how did you come up with that
VC my idea. overring priority was getting funding for network transformation which was hard during austerity – unless something dramatic was done network would collapse. needed cash and commitment to turn it round.
FP so that object was pre-eminent – was the second objective [separation] linked to it
VC don't think so – those were tech and legal matters handled well by Ed Davey. Mutualisation which I did care about, needed to be addressed. NFSP were behind it.
FP separation already existed as an idea? Labour raised that
VC yes
FP securing funding for NT was made. Second objective – separation also a success and raised £3.3bn for the treasury
VC we maybe could have got more but it was considered a success
… but this was also about allowing RMG to survive – it was dying.
FP I asked if the two were interlinked – and you suggested not. Are you saying Treasury would have given PO £2bn if it didn't know it was going to get £3.3bn for the RMG sale
VC no not connected
… the big cost to the treasury was the pension deficit that swamped everything. The reason we got the cash for the PO was vital for the country and that's how we made the case.
FP but you couldn't sell RMG without solving the pension pot problem – £28bn funding for a £37.5bn…
… of liabilities. That had to be dealt with.
VC yes
FP those issues were interralted – no funding for PO without £27bn plus £3.3bn in the sale of RMG
VC no not related
FP how did people know about your 3 priorities
VC I told them about it – CEO Chair and PO ministers
FP in July 2013 you made an announcement in parly about privatisation. Shortly before that Jo Swinson had to give a reaction in parly to the 2S Interim Report which noted that the 2S report had not impact on RMG

FP takes VC to a whips briefing behind Jo Swinson's statement
FP here's the point. Essential to stop 2S's report not get in the way of what you were trying to do re RMG separation

VC no I got involved. found out about risk factors – H was not disco'd. CWU strike was the big one.
FP so this 2S stuff was not something that was coming directly from you – but you had communicated your 3 objectives and people were making them happen
VC yes – that involved managing a group of risk factors, but I don't remember this one being raised at the time – it might be that H was concerning some people, but the brokers and risk managers would have raised and they didn't
FP we know that PV tried to remove the H risk factor from the RMG prospectus. there were people trying to remove H risk from separation
VC accepts
FP takes VC to email between PV and AP re finessing the 2S report "caught up in something bigger"

FP something bigger and more sensitive – this is 1 July 2013 – JS made her statement on 8 July and your statement on separation was 9 July – the bigger thing is the privatisation – does that make sense?
VC yes
FP are you confident no one in govt wasn't putting pressure on the PO
VC don't know. ShEx were managing PO and privatisation – no idea if they acted in the manner you ar suggesting
[FP ends – Sam Stein KC now (SS) for more SPMs]
SS goes back to info VC's office received throughout his tenure as SoS. This was a doc from May 2012 – exactly 2 years into VC's tenure

SS this is written evidence submitted by Shoosmiths solicitors

SS reads from it – brings up par 7

SS goes over the page and reads par 8

SS so we have a description by par 8 from a national law firm about a fundamental problem with the IT system and the PO – competent cogent submissions. Did this get to you
VC no
SS help us understand how. This is a public consultation
VC don't know – my own perceptions were based on contacts with individual SPMs and I was aware terrible things were happening. Found out about one in my own constituency where an SPM thinks he made a mistake. That's how I became aware. In 2013 the NFSP came to me…
… with a scrapbook full of photos with SPMs in a terrible state. The theory they had was that mistakes were being made and they were being brutally punished for it. The NFSP when they came to see me confirmed that view, but this was never disco'd in terms of H.
SS
par 8 – false accounting
par 9 – losses
par 10 – repaying
par 12 – false accounting
these were all matters were never investigated never taken to your level
VC correct
SS comes to NFSP par 17 – the gov is being told lucidly and cogently in 2012 what is happening and BIS did what
VC no idea. re NFSP I had limited but positive dealings. I asked help with an SPM who'd lost £100k – thought they were an effective trade union

SS this is 2012 – you've said in your evidence that by the time we get to 2015 you realised something bad was happening but that was at the end of your time and you wish you could have done more. Jacqueline Falcon was prosecuted…
… by the CPS for fraud in 2015 – she'd worked for the PO for 15 years. In 2014 she had a loss of less than £1000 was told that she was being prosecuted and should plead guilty which she did. So bad things were happening.
What did you do to tell your successor…
… about this.
VC nothing. i was unemployed. previous administrations do not tell the incoming administrations what's happening. Had I met Sajid Javid, my successor, I would have told him.
SS in 2017/8/9 we had the Bates v Post Office court case
VC wasn't aware
SS when were you
VC when journalists started asking me about it after it was all over – lost all contact with this in 2015
SS so when you got back into parly did you look into this at all?
VC no
VC would only have done it if I found an SPM in Twickenham
SS if you had engaged with these issues you could buttonhole the ministers or SoS at the time – what you criticised other MPs for
VC had I known about it, yes, but in 2017 Brexit took up all the bandwidth
… apart from constituency issues which I raised. And the Saudi arms deal which followed me and half a dozen others from my time at BIS, but not the PO.
SS did anyone in gov come to you and say Sir Vince we've got issues with the PO in the High Court…
… did anyone ask you what you were told?
VC no I wish they had, they didn't
[Sir Vince finishes his evidence. we break for lunch. Greg Clark is next at around 2pm]
whilst we are waiting do watch yesterday's HoL debate – kindly clipped out by @chrish9070
x.com/chrish9070/status/1816141645458338132
#PostOfficeScandal Earlier this afternoon in the @UKHouseofLords they had a short debate on the UQ presented last week in the other chamber @HouseofCommons by former Minister @kevinhollinrake
Asked about the exoneration letters (which we now have an answer to from my earlier tweet). Lord Fox asked about those not included in the legislation by way of already having their appeal rejected or refused by the CofA and then Lord Sikka @premnsikka raising the issue of the DWP cases that have also been excluded. The further batch of people excluded is the Capture cases which I am sure Lord Jones (@RtHonKevanJones ) will continue championing from this House.
Unfortunately the Minister Baroness Jones didn’t really seem to understand what was asked, saying they would be covered in the final report. That just shows a lack of understanding of the situation. There needs to be an urgent review of DWP cases similar to the review being carried out for Capture cases. Records have been destroyed, court transcripts no longer exist so these people (including sadly deceased individuals) do not stand a chance unless these cases are independently reviewed, lets not allow them to make the same mistake they have all these years refusing to engage until every avenue of defence and deflection had failed.
Debate online now from parliamentlive.tv
#MrBatesVsThePostOffice #MrBates #MrBatesVsPostOffice #MrBatesPBS #PostOfficeInquiry #HouseofLords
Or you could listen to this.
x.com/mountforduk/status/1816442251100184874
The latest episode of The Innocence Podcast: “Fighting for the Sub-Postmasters” is now live.
This episode features Mountford barrister, @edwardhenry1, and @FloraClairePage of @23essexstreet Barristers’ Chambers, who are part of the legal team fighting for sub-postmasters wrongfully convicted due to the faulty Horizon computer system.
Journalist @nickwallis, who has extensively covered this story, joins the discussion, shedding light on this significant miscarriage of justice in the UK.
Listen on Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/the-innocence-podcast/id1615808386?i=1000663176461
#PostOfficeInquiry #SubPostmasters
I've had to bail so I'm not live-tweeting Greg Clark's evidence, but I am watching it on the hoof. I'll try to get something up tonight.
Thanks.

