Day 151 of the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry.
129 tweets
Welcome to Day 151 of the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry at Aldwych House in London. We await Andy Parsons second day of evidence, which I will live tweet, with documents… 🧵

About ten minutes ago I bumped into Andy Parsons in the loo. I said "Hello Andy, how are you?"
He did not reply. I wrote this about him yesterday:
www.postofficescandal.uk/post/post-office-lawyer-postmasters-are-liars/
#PostOfficeScandal #PostOfficeInquiry
If you'd like to support my work from the Inquiry and get the irregular "secret email" newsletter too, please have a look at how to do that here:
www.postofficescandal.uk/donate/
We're underway. Jason Blake is asking the questions

Starts the month before the first trial in Bates v Post Office. Internal email noting that Richard Roll is going to be a witness for the Subpostmasters and that Steve Parker knew him and needs to be a witness for the PO

JB did the witness receive witness training
AP don't know if he did, but we offered it to all witnesses through a third party
JB support
AP can't remember with regard to Steve Parker

JB takes him to Steve Parker (SP)'s email refusing to be a witness
JB do you know who the other witness is SP is referring to?
AP no

AP's reply

Email reply – saying that John Simpkins did not want to be a witness either
JB why was this?
AP don't know
JB aware of the Anne Chambers issue in the Castleton case?
AP no one told me about that

JB strategy options for litigation steering group
JB did you produce this (in-joke from yesterday, possibly)
AP me or my team

JB highlights the "attrition" option

This is what Parsons looks like today btw

[also pls note that nothing I post is a direct quote unless it is in "direct quotes". It is a summary or characterisation of what is being said. The source docs are all real tho – screenshotted from the live feed, which you can watch here. www.youtube.com/channel/UCgijUpaux8X4Nvjx3TmrHhg]
JB takes him to AP's comment on the "attrition" strategy where he disclaims it

JB did it matter to you that the client was owned by the govt?
AP I saw this an ordinary piece of commercial litigation.
JB reads on…

Rest of par 358

JB so you did not rec an attrition strategy, but it might have been a by-product of other strategies
AP sort of agrees
JB takes him to another steering group doc from 11 Sep 2017
JB you write this?
AP me or my team

JB takes him to this
JB so not take each case to a conclusion
AP didn't think that was feasible
JB reads 4.3

JB so you're not advocating a strategy of attrition but we need to keep an eye on the litigation funders
AP yes they'll drop their case if the merits of the case fall below a certain level – so a merit-based strategy
JB did this change over time
AP we did get the sense the litigants were struggling with funding at some points, as were we to be fair – but everything was always done on merit
JB takes him to a doc in which AP suggests keeping "a Positive (if deluded) mental attitude!"

JB you write "force the Cs to burn money" – is that the strategy
AP no – straw man discussion between litigators – never advice to the client
JB what's the different between a brain dump and advice to a client

JB it's your view
AP it's a view – a starter for ten amongst the legal team
This is the judge's view (i think this is his second judgment)

[Forgive me – it's the third Common Issues trial judgment]
[JB takes him to a 2018 email from AP's junior colleague Amy Prime about a meeting with govt over the litigation]

JB was there an worry about sharing info with govt
AP yes
JB were you concerned?
AP always concerned about privilege
JB do you recall a concern about gov giving info to the CCRC

JB Scrolling down – was there an issue with Tom Cooper being able to speak freely?
AP no recall

JB verbal advice – paperwork to a minimum – this is consistent with your advice we saw yesterday – did you give this advice
AP don't think so – there was an issue with the number of written updates required
JB yes but verbal updates here – recall this
AP PO had concerns about…
… where written updates would go

Another email re protocol for being able to communicate between govt, lawyers and PO.
JB reads the email – Post Office refusing to provide written updates to its shareholder!!

[PO's response is to suggest a verbal update. Brilliant]

JB a call is suggested – remember it
AP not the detail

JB to what extent were the govt properly sighted on the litigation
AP can't comment – that was mainly covered in house
JB what extent did the PO want to share info with UKGI
AP Rod and Jane McLeod wanted to maintain privilege over info they gave govt
JB did you provide advice on that matter to them
AP [essentially] yes
[we have moved on to some documents relating to Brian Altman's review of the CK review – so we're back in 2013]

JB how were these minutes approved?
AP BA approved them
JB highlights this par in the draft

JB these are the finished minutes

JB the highlighted par has changed

JB shows another example – pre approved minutes

Approved minutes

[JB is showing the changes in minutes side by side]
JB quite a lot of care taken over these minutes? Is that what your firm did
AP can't comment
JB section on BA advising considerable caution – was that in the meeting
AP that was the tenor
JB takes him to Simon Clarke' notes of the meetin

This is the Bond Dickinson version
JB why was the reference to SImon Clarke's second advice not in the BD minutes?

AP don't know didn't take the minutes
JB do you remember what was said in the meeting
AP I don't remember the meeting
JB you remember being there
AP yes, but don't remember what was said
[we're on a break – if you're thirsting for something to read, here's the legal gossip site Roll On Friday's take on Parsons' evidence yesterday. They were a lot less kind than me: www.rollonfriday.com/news-content/wombles-partners-torn-apart-post-office-inquiry]
[okay we're back in the room – JB has finished asking questions for the inquiry – Chris Jacobs is now asking questions on behalf of SPMs via Howe and Co]
Chris Jacobs (CJ) – you became too close to your client – asked them if they should attack SPMs – instead of taking a step back – you conspired with them
AP my language was too strong, but I thought my clients had a case
CJ did you conspire with your client to downplay matters to keep important info out of the public domain
AP no conspiracy – we emphasised matters we thought were important and de-emphasised views we didn't agree with
CJ takes AP to an email from 17 June 2014
CJ reads "point of concern" par 3

[the M060 CQR is a subpostmaster application to the complaint and mediation scheme]
[we scroll down – CJ reads out. the highlighted par]
CJ this shows that you were concerned that the SPMs were about to find out that Gareth Jenkins (GJ) was not credible

AP the HR report has two discrete issues in it – the GJ issue and the reversal of transactions – my primary focus on the HR report was the latter. Reading this again now was the disclosure/GJ issue
CJ but it's YOU giving the advice to downplay the importance of the HR report – not Cartwright King (CK)
AP that was one of the concerns – but I had just spoken to CK and that "our approach" is a joint decision
CJ the HR report was a Pandora's Box as it would stop the PO from being able to reverse the burden of proof on the SPMR
AP it was there to be read
CJ not Jenkins name
AP that's what the crim lawyers said
CJ you advised it should stay redacted
AP on advice from the crim lawyers
CJ takes him to Jarnail Singh's reply – what circs is JS talking about
AP I don't know
CJ you must understand the circs
AP reading that now I can't tell you what JS is thinking
CJ was he thinking about the Clarke Advice?
AP possibly

CJ so you were covering up for your client the existence of the Clarke Advice
AP no – there is a q for the crim lawyers re GJ's name redaction from the HR report. I'm looking at this from the perspective re the scheme
CJ you gave this advice
AP yes but it was CK's too
CJ if you hadn't advised the PO to downplay the GJ issues in 2014, the last ten years of the lives of SPMs would be very different
AP that's down to the decisions the PO made in 2013 about their criminal disclosure
CJ notes from AP's WS he attended two mediation meetings – most were attended by other WBD lawyers in AP's team – you say PO was mediating in good faith
AP it was
CJ but it wasn't tho
AP I didn't get that impression
CJ Peter Holloway – former SPM went to mediation – he prepared a lot. And he recalls speaking to a "haggard" mediator late in the day who said not only were the PO refusing to settle – they had no authority to do so
AP we looked at each case on its merits – some we…
… advised to settle, some not to settle but we sent them to mediate anyway. I can see how that might be frustrating, but that's how we approached it – in good faith
CJ for those who did get offers, they were derisory, weren't they, with a view simply to strengthen your case…
… for a possible future litigation.
AP no we did this in good faith
CJ Alan Bates says "I believe the mediation scheme failed as it was part of a cover-up by the PO" – no intention whatsoever of getting to a mutually acceptable result – it was a fishing expedition…
… to find out how much SPMs knew about the Horizon (H) system
AP don't accept that – we did it in good faith
CJ in your WS you haven't made any apology or statement of regret for your actions – many of our clients have been aghast at the emails we were taken to in your…
… evidence yesterday. One of our clients said your evidence yesterday displayed "arrogance", "deceit", "corporate corruption" and was "an absolute disgrace" – do you have anything to say
AP apologises
[CJ's evidence ends]
[Ed Henry KC for more SPMs starts]
EH you didn't make any mistakes at all did you – it was a deliberate strategy – what you did was deliberate, clear sighted and ruthless
AP I'm a lawyer acting for PO – i have to defend their interests – during my engagement I had…
… been told it was a reliable system and our strategy was based on that.
EH you must have seen there were huge gaps in that belief, but you didn't confront them on that
AP my clients believed the system was safe, but they were open to the idea it didn't
EH the mediation scheme was bad faith
AP no
EH why send an email saying you thought no cases would succeed
AP that was well before it was finalised
EH tell me about the meeting on 9 Sep 2013 –
AP can't remember any of it
EH don't want to
AP no, can't
EH you set up the meeting
AP yes
EH big deal – this meeting wasn't it
AP accepts
EH you were the most junior person in the room?
AP yes
EH Jarnail Singh is there – he's not taking many notes – Susan Crichton maybe not, Rod Williams – would he
AP usually
EH Martin Smith was there – he typed notes – your boss was there – so you would be the deputed note-taker
AP I haven't found any notes
EH would you have taken them in notebooks or on a laptop
AP written
EH do you have any recollection of taking notes
AP no
EH but you would be the person to take notes – you would want to impress
AP impress who
EH your partner
AP […]
EH takes him to the WBD notes – these were sanitised – weren't they – no reference to crawling out of the woodwork – any recollection of that
AP no
EH no recollection of your senior asking if PO should apologise to Seema Misra and Altman saying I wouldn't
AP no recollection
EH no mention of GJ's breaching his duties in the minutes
AP don't recall
EH were the PO not bound to disclose the GJ info to Seema?
AP that's for the crim lawyers
EH no – you have a brain – were they not bound to disclose it
AP yes – that's what I understood from the crim lawyers
EH and yet there's no mention of it in the minutes – is that not odd
AP yes that is odd
[EH takes him to a 2012 doc]
EH this shows what was in the background all the time

EH reads out par 2 in full
EH so this identifies the pre-2010 cases as a problem
AP yes
EH reads par 3

EH so there was an awareness that behind the dam were hundreds of SPMs who potentially had a civil claim and/or had been convicted of a crime
AP I wasn't there then, but there was always an awareness at the PO that if Horizon was found to be…
… fundamentally flawed there would be a wide range of potential liabilities
EH so you had to keep it all at bay – that was the policy
AP no in 2013 I was told the PO believed it was reliable – 2S said there was no systemic issue and that was the belief at the time
EH you remember on 8 Oct 2013 you made a presentation to the Sparrow working group didn't you
AP I may have done
EH gets the powerpoint slides back up – "slow to concede H has any tech faults"

AP they believed it was reliable – on reflection the bar was set too high
EH look what it says their "flood of claims" – so you knew even then
AP it was a recognition
EH and if the pin comes out of the grenade you can't predict where the shrapnel is going to end up
AP there was a concern there might be a fault with H causing problems but there was no evidence of that and that's what we're trying to get to the bottom of
EH did you like Second Sight (2S)
AP on a personal level yes
EH takes him to an email

EH so Dan Faucet had access to 2S's emails? Who was he
AP lawyer at WBD
EH how did he have access to 2S's emails
AP at the end of the 2S investigation they had to hand them back
EH so were you trying to get dirt on them
AP there was a concern…
… and so I forwarded it
EH who instructed you to review 2S's emails
AP can't recall – it could be that PO received a lot of Data Access Subject requests and it could be they were being reviewed in that context
[goes to a new email chain from Feb 2014]
EH what's going on here
AP context here is that 2S said at a Working Group meeting they had info about crim cases

EH takes him to AP warning Ron W off

EH who was heavily scrutinising Ron W's comments
AP wasn't specific
EH why gently warn him?
AP RW had said he had info relevant to prosecutions and that provoked a response from PO as to how to get it if we needed it – I then spoke to him he accepted he had no new info
… and so it didn't matter, so I told him to be careful in future not to set hares running
EH why not say that then
AP I think I've answered that
EH at its most anodyne this was an attempt to move 2S away from their invesetigations into crim cases
AP no
EH at its worst this was a threat
AP no – and there was a letter from 2S which
EH you were trying to shut this down
AP no
EH you're quite good at closing things down which shut down the lessons learned review or diluted it because you were concerned about disclosure – remember that?
AP we were pointing out the risks – not saying it shouldn't go forward
EH you also positioned Mr Altman so he didn't need to call out a miscarriage of justice
AP no nothing like that
EH you said he should not opine on safety and whether or not his advice should be private or public
AP I recall that
EH and some to-ing and fro-ing on him setting his terms of reference
AP don't believe I was involved in that
[EH takes him to a new doc]
EH what's the political dimension here
AP the MPs
EH PO must not fail
AP don't recognise that comment

[new email]

Ends

EH help us how Brian Altman can help you with the civil side as explained by Gavin Matthews
AP don't understand the comment about BA helping with the civil side
EH all about the dam again isnt' it
AP if H was found to be fundamentally flawed it would give rise to liabilities
EH would only take one case where there was proper disclosure in accordance with the law and the whole dam would collapse
AP didn't think about it like that
EH but you don't understand what GM had in mind when he drafted this sentence about BA
AP no
EH solicitors have a fundamental duty to act in a way which upholds justice
AP one of the duties – some of which aren't necessarily responsible
EH did BA advise on Seema Misra (SM)
AP don't recall
EH he wanted her outwith the mediation process as it might give her a ground of appeal
AP CK did not want convicted SPMs in the scheme
EH I'm talking about SM specifically
AP can't recall
EH what happens if a crim lawyer is giving advice you don't understand it or you think its wrong – you have to do something don't you
AP if I had that awareness I would
EH you agreed the PO was bound to disclose re GJ
AP that was my understanding from the crim lawyers
EH wants to deal with SM directly – goes to a doc

Full email

EH so by 1 July 2013 you were up to speed by Misra
AP no we had a very narrow remit
EH you say you think you pinned down what happened with Misra
[EH takes him to this and there is some debate as to whether AP or even WBD created it]

EH takes him to pars 30 – 32

[debate continues about who originated the document]
EH SM should have been provided with info about GJ shouldn't they?
AP now yes I think so – but we were being advised by CK and I didn't see there being a problem with the crim lawyers advice
EH the draft letter to the CCRC [which we saw yesterday] does not contain any mention of the GJ issue
AP it was a holding letter
EH it's indefensible isn't it
AP what is
EH the omission of GJ's failures in the eyes of the law and you continue to trade of BA's advice going forward
AP not my recollection – they were seriously concerned
EH they were seriously concerned because the Clarke Advice was the pin in the grenade and they wanted to keep the pin in the grenade wasn't it
AP not my recollection – didn't have sight of the crim lawyers decisions
EH advice is given by you that the BA report gives good grounds to resist external examinations – ie from the CCRC – you don't mention SM in that document
AP don't recall her being mentioned
EH so all that rottenness and taint re the architect of the system…
… and the tainted witness (GJ) was airbrushed away.
AP no there was a process and the process was followed
EH buried under this aura of respectability, but underneath this was the basic failure to hand over info to seema's lawyers which was obvious
AP appears to be the case
EH takes him back to the PO notification to the insurers written by AP – undermined "a prosecution case" – that's a reference to Seema Misra
AP no – that's not there has been a single prosecution case – I'm reading that differently

EH takes him to the draft which suggests it is just one case and it must be SM
AP don't know what it's referring to. I didn't write that bit

EH if GJ was disclosed to SM it would have exploded – not just the appeals but the handling of GJ by PO management
AP accepts SM having a successful appeal would have serious implications for the PO
EH and on remote access too – it would have been catastrophic
AP yes
EH takes him to this

EH then takes him to another doc – 9 April 2014
[not sure I've seen this before – Simon Clarke stating that the only disclosure issue was the unsafe witness point]

EH so we know that BA and SC thought that GJ's credibility failures were the main disclosure issues
AP yes
EH did it not strike you as incredibly odd that these two incredibility experienced lawyers were dancing around the elephant in the room
AP not at the time now
[EH finishes – now Claire Dobbin for Gareth Jenkins]
CD so here we see that some work had been done on the Misra trial
AP yes anything relating to specific bugs
CD yes and you said you didn't see anything about the three bugs mentioned by 2S
AP yes but that was wrong
CD did you read the transcripts of the Misra trial
AP no
CD re the 14 bug that came to light after the Misra trial – the suspense account bug
AP 2012
CD and came to Fujitsu (F) in 2013
CD at the time did anyone explain that Mr Wilson – a prosecutor working on the case decided that notes relating to that bug should not be disclosed to Mrs Misra
AP did not know that
CD did you speak to Jarnail Singh about knowledge of bugs or the Misra trial?
AP No
CD your firm recommended in the instruction of leading counsel BA because of a possible conflict with CK
AP I recall that
CD ought that information – that they knew in 2013 that there was a serious issue re GJ's instruction… should that information have been brought…
… to your attention?
AP we were a conduit to BA
CD but how would he know that information if no one told him
AP our role was to allow information flow between Brian and what he wanted to find out
CD during the civil litigation did you set out info to Fujitsu re how GJ was to be handled
AP no knowledge of this – but F were not aware of the concerns about GJ – at least that's my understanding
CD and you were the key person in the conduct of the group litigation
CD so GJ didn't know what position he was in re the GLO
AP can't speak to that – but as far as I was aware he was not aware
CD how could you let that situation arise? you were making use of GJ but not…
… letting them know how and why they were being used
AP it was a less than ideal situation – we thought we might be able not to use him, but as the issues took shape we realised we did
CD you put him in a position without him knowing about it
AP he was a source of info
CD you didn't see you were potentially exposing him or putting him in a position
AP not sure what difficulties you are envisaging – we were asking him questions and he was answering them – what's the prob?
CD you don't see a problem with that – using…
… someone in litigation, being very cautious in using them and then not telling them that?
AP there are difficulties for PO people to manage – did not cross my mind.
[evidence ends. Andy Parsons is done]
I'l try to get the key points from today up shortly. I'm told there are some interesting comments running about Parsons' evidence underneath Roll On Friday's piece www.rollonfriday.com/news-content/wombles-partners-torn-apart-post-office-inquiry]
Other legal gossip websites are no doubt available.
I'm going to grab some of the samosas Varchas brought along before they all go and then try to find somewhere quiet to write this up.
Thanks for reading. If you want to support my work…

