Ian Henderson and Ron Warmington

Day 152 of the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry.

268 tweets

Good morning from the Post Office IT Inquiry at Aldwych House in London. Evidence from these two today, Ron Warmington (left) and Ian Henderson (right) of Second Sight. This will be a thread of live tweets. I bumped into…

Ian on Kingsway this morning and asked him how he was feeling. "I've been waiting eleven years for this!" he said. In Mr Bates vs The Post Office Bob Rutherford is a composite of Ian and Ron. Ian's middle name is Rutherford. Ian is being sworn in now.

There's an almost party atmosphere in the inquiry room today. Many Subpostmasters are here, including two couples who have flown over from Northern Ireland. There is a lot of affection for Ron and Ian for what they achieved. I wrote up my thoughts on the two of them…

… in my last newsletter. You can subscribe to future editions of newsletter here with a one-off donation of as much or as little as you like: www.postofficescandal.uk/donate/

This pays for my presence at the inquiry and the Post Office Scandal website.

NB: Nothing I tweet is a direct quote unless it in "direct quotes". It's summary/characterisation of what's being said. Here's Ian (IH) taking the oath

… Jason Beer KC is asking the questions.

IH is taken to a memo from Susan Crichton (SC Post Office (PO) general counsel to PO chair Alice Perkins (AP) and CEO Paula Vennells (PV)) explaining the plan to get Second Sight (2S) involved

Objectives and scope…
JB were you hired to do a code examination
IH no

JB now takes him to a meeting between 2S and MPs

JB takes him to the minute where IH says they weren't going to do a code review – is that accurate
IH yes we weren't software engineers we were forensic accountants

JB takes IH to an email from Ron Warmington (RW) telling SC what they had said to MPs

JB RW says that you did not tell MPs you were going to do a deep dive into Horizon (H)
IH yes

JB so you recommended against a system-based code review
IH yes
JB did you ever recommend it
IH we were always open to that possibility and I think after we were terminated one was posited but not quite followed through
JB by who
IH PO
JB do you know why it was never carried out

IH no
JB takes IH to his Witness Statement (WS)
JB why was it not straightforward
IH it was in my experience unique – PO were paying us but we were being directed by the JFSA and the MPs

JB why do you think you were appointed
IH cheap but competent. It's clear the PO did not want this review.
JB you came to regret that PO were your clients
IH our terms of ref were appointed by the MPs but we signed…

… confidentiality agreements and non-disclosure issues with the PO
JB was that a problem
IH it was certainly unusual
JB you investigated 140 cases whilst working for the PO
IH yes
JB only in England and Wales
IH yes
JB was that deliberate?

IH no I think it was just those that came through to us
JB goes back to IH's WS – your remit was to consider systemic issues from the very start
IH yes
JB was that remit too broad
IH there was some difficulty with the term systemic and widely misunderstood

JB who by
IH I was using it in the terms of system-wide – Alan Bates was using it in a more narrow way
JB was the effect of using system-wide in your Interim Report (IR) something that allowed the PO to distract from the problems with the system
IH [essentially] yes

JB takes him to his WS par 78 – did you make this clear to the PO at the time?
IH it was a preliminary view. Not sure I expressed it perhaps properly to the PO at the time

JB were you frustrated that the PO picked up on your line about the lack of system-wide issues
IH it was unfortunate
JB you worked in the Post Office next to Jarnail Singh in the legal dept – what was it like
IH quite old-fashioned. Everything was on paper and printed out…

… relatively small. Outsourcing was part of the policy. There were only 10 or 12 legal case files available to me.
JB you were surprised at the small size of the legal dept – why?
IH given the size of the PO I only met ten lawyers – that seemed small
JB you said the PO had…

… problems getting case files under control – what do you mean?
IH that everything was decentralised
JB you say SC relied on Jarnail Singh (JS) for criminal matters
IH yes
JB he was your main day-to-day contact within the PO
IH yes

JB what was he like
IH more an administrator than a lawyer – his level of knowledge of prosecutions was quite limited. I was having to do my homework eg code of crown prosecutors. I put technical questions to him and quite often he couldn't answer

JB how long were you in the PO legal dept
IH a number of weeks
JB takes him to par 77 of his WS

… ends over the page.
JB subequently – does that mean after June 2013?
IH can't quite remember – it was only when I was listening to Simon Clarke's evidence to this inquiry I remembered the bug info had not been disclosed to Seema Misra

JB what do you remember about seeing this at the time?
IH it's quite vague
JB but you saw this in her file at Old Street
IH yes
JB was it ring bound
IH it was a spring bound – do you know what I mean?
JB I am too young
[I think IH means lever-arch file]

[they agree on what they're talking about]
JB was this bound?
IH now it was a working file
JB was it kept in a filing cabinet
IH assume so – they were produced to me – I had 10 hard copy files on my desk and worked through those
JB in terms of the R&M bug doc – what was it

IH a file note prepared by Gareth Jenkins (GJ) dated 2010
JB takes him to it [they agree it is that doc, but we don't see it]
IH that's it
JB you say in your WS that this was the subject of a PII application – who told you that
IH Simon Clarke's evidence to the inquiry

Inquiry chair Sir Wyn Williams (SWW) intervenes to get this nailed down – you say that R&M bug and Local suspense bug were disclosed in June 2013, then you say the R&M bug was in Seema Misra's file. When did you see the doc exactly – before or after the IR was published.

IH it was included in the documents we did hold – but I can't remember when I saw it.
JB moves to Jo Hamilton (JH)'s case file
IH by happenstance it was the first file I looked at in any order

[sorry ignore "in any order" – going mad]

we go to JH's POIR – this was the name given to the docs which summarised the PO's view of each individual case being investigated in the Complaint and Mediation Scheme (MS)

JB was this typical
IH was yes – not a proper investigation in my view.
JB takes him to the Security Team report into JH's case

[this is the crucial information which got the 2015 Panorama commissioned]

JB so this was provided to you
IH yes this was the Brander report – but this was one of lots of versions which we never quite got to the bottom of
JB yes – want to explore that a bit

JB highlights the crucial "unable to find any evidence of theft" – important
IH astonishing
JB because you knew JH had been charged with theft
IH yes

JB now – nothing about this report is marked as privileged
IH correct
JB and you referred to this report in your final investigation into JH
IH yes
JB did you know these reports were to get legal advice from the PO legal team
IH difficult q to answer

JB did you feel inhibited in referring to it in your final report
IH no
JB let's see what you did [takes him to the 2S CRR – case review report into JH]

JB Notes at the top of this page 2S refer to the Brander report as a doc 2S were provided with…

JB takes him to 2S's conclusions on this and reads from it "no evidence of theft"

JB then reads 4.11

Over the page…

[it's worth remembering at the time the PO tried to poo-poo 2S by saying they were accountants not lawyers]

JB are your conclusions there founded in part from the conclusion in the Brander report that there was no evidence of theft
IH yes
JB significant
IH yes – exculpatory evidence which had NOT been disclosed to JH
JB and you were pointing this out to the PO
IH yes

JB let's see what happened next. Takes him to a letter to RW and IH from Rodric Williams drafted by Andy Parsons

[this is a despicable attempt at a cover-up of an obvious miscarriage of justice]

JB reads on

It ends…

2S reply robustly

it continues

And ends (JB is reading it out)

JB you explain in your WS was to create a new investigation report (POIR) which deleted any mention of the original Brander report. Correct?
IH yes
[JB takes him to the doc]

JB notes the PO removed the Brander report and then renumbered the docs – so…
JB PO set up a scheme to get to the bottom of the SPMR complaints, they get you in, they disclose an important document to you, you refer to it in the report, then you…

… get a telling off from the PO and JH is refused the document. And then the PO produce a new POIR in which the offending Brander report it airbrushed out.
IH correct
JB you found Williams' assertion absurd
IH yes

JB and that's when you became concerned about a cover-up
IH yes
JB was this one-off conduct by the PO
IH I suspect not
JB was this correspondence typical
IH yes
JB did it occur throughout

IH their attitude changed over time – when we were first appointed there was a shared commitment to seek the truth but as things progressed the PO became much more adversarial and…

… they didn't want difficult info to see the light of day and we had to fight for access to relevant doc
JB you say you couldn't get access to legal files
IH we did originally – I was there in the dept, but we couldn't get hold of them subsequently

JB reading the corr it looks like the PO disclosed the Brander report to you by mistake
IH I think what actually happened was there was a small number of files disclosed to us by SC and JS. Andy Parsons wasn't involved till the MS kicked off and that's when the PO started…

… getting concerned about disclosing documents to us.
JB takes him back to his WS par 39

over the page.
JB when were you told this
IH in the initial stages of my work – when I was sitting in the legal dept
JB so you spotted it then
IH as an apparent inconsistency which concerned me

JB when JS said everything had been disclosed
– was he talking about crim disclosure
IH that was the context
JB were you concerned about what he said
IH I was very concerned – it appeared to be a breach of the Code of Prosecutors which he had a duty to comply with

JB were you concerned about SC's reliance on JS
IH yes he was a crim lawyer and she was a commercial lawyer – she was supervising a dept with crim lawyers in it and so she had to rely on him

JB did you raise this
IH yes with both of them. don't know what the PO did about it
[first morning break]

[we're back]
JB good morning sir can you continue to see and hear us
SWW yes thank you [SWW is chairing remotely as he does most days]

We go to a new document. PO Internal email exchange re meeting which 2S attended
JB by Sep 2012 were you frustrated with lack of docs PO provided
IH yes we were

JB goes to point 4 – had you formed a view the PO were bad at investigations
IH only from looking at their case files – no discos with the investigations team
JB is that why you wanted to view some live cases
IH yes

JB so when you looked at the original 10 to 12 case files at the start of your investigation – did you get sight of the instructions between the investigation team and lawyers
IH yes and my permission to look at these came from SC
JB did you get that throughout your investigation

IH no it changed when the PO realised we were getting quite critical of their investigations
JB so there was a link in your mind between your criticism and the access you were getting
IH yes
JB did the PO explain the class of documents it held about problems with H?

IH not really properly explained to us like that – I formed the impression the PO didn't really care that much about H – it was a black box which worked as they needed it to. They didn't really understand it

JB did they tell you whether there was a central repository of material held about issues concerning deficiencies in H
IH we asked that q and were told there was not single case file
JB did they tell you about release notes which documented bug fixes
IH what about major…

… incident reports and service management docs
IH no
JB did you get told about emails, reports and minutes of meetings regarding bugs of which PO was already aware
IH we eventually got some limited disclosure, but that was much later on and after I met Gareth Jenkins from…

… Fujitsu.
JB but at the initial stages – did the PO come to you and say – we already know these things – the Falkirk Sq bug or the R&M bug
IH no none of that was disclosed at that stage
JB any IT expert reports the PO had commissioned from past court cases –
IH no

JB any categories of docs relevant to your investigation – KELs or PEAKs or PINICLs
IH no
JB get told about any defendants raising the faulty operation of H
IH no
JB did you get the op documents setting out the facility for remote acces
IH no
JB what did they give you?

[laughter]
IH the consistent info we got was that the PO believed H was working well with no faults or errors
JB but you were given prosecution files to look at
IH yes

JB were you given the names of acquitted individuals Nichola Arch, Susan Palmer, Maureen McElvey
IH not at that stage, no

JB goes to IH's WS – reads from it – what was CD1?
IH in Sep 2012 2S realised it needed to preserve and control the prosecution files we were getting, so we asked all the files be sent off to be scanned into searchable pdfs. By that stage I'd done a manual review and realised

… there was a significant amount of info which could give rise to miscarriages of justice

JB this was in Oct 2012 – did you share this with the PO?
IH yes
JB who?
IH SC and JS. SC relied on JS and JS said there's nothing to do, we've done everything

JB so what happened to your concern
IH we parked it at that point as we wanted to get access to more files
JB did you consider sharing your views with the Crown Office in Scotland
IH no
JB did you know they were still prosecuting in Scotland
IH no

JB takes him to an email ex from May 2013

JB if you'd already raised your concerns with the PO about potential miscarrs – can you ask why the PO were asking you to confirm there were no miscarrs
IH point 2 relates to systemic defects and miscarrs. We weren't aware of point 2a, but we had concerns about point 2b

JB takes him to RWs response

JB would this not have been an oppo to reply saying you already have concerns about miscarrs and have raised it
IH yes that would have been the way to do it – experts needed to investigate
JB yes but if you had formed a view that poor investigations and disclosure failings…

… and other misconduct, it was not here in this email or your IR in July 2013
IH we were keen not to stray outside our remit
JB you could have made the point tho – we are inexprt in this field and we have seen things which need to be investigated
IH yes we should…

… have done more to highlight these problems but we were equally aware of the pushback from the PO about our expertise
JB was that a constant refrain from the PO
IH yes we were made aware of it and knew we would be challenged if we raised matters outside our competence –

… quite rightly.

JB what is this?
IH looks like one of our reports

JB You raise the a meeting note to discuss the R&M bug – we are familiar with that. How did you get to see it?
IH I think it was fiven to us by Simon Baker – our main PO/Fujitsu liaison

JB when did you come by them? we have no evidence as to when you got the meeting note
IH shortly before our pt2 report
JB but it came from Simon B
IH yes

JB takes him back to IH's WS – Gareth Jenkins and remote access!

… over the page

JB reads out the follow – par 47 gets laughter in the room

… and more…

continues…

… par 47 ends [when I told this to Simon Baker for my book he said he didn't remember being told this by Ron or Ian]

JB why did you ask for emails etc, when all you could have done was ask GJ for a signed statement confirming the contents of your conversation

IH yes and we probably should – the meeting with GJ I had always seen as a preliminary meeting to get some direct contact from the H lead engineer and even tho I only had one meeting we did have quite extensive follow up corr where he sent me reports and docs

JB takes him to IH's WS for the Horizon Issues trial in Bates v PO

JB Reads from the GJ doc
JB in your current WS you say GJ said remote access was "routinely" used. In the 2018 WS you say "occasionally" used. Which is more accurate?

IH on reflection I realise GJ was talking about many different things – remote access by connecting to a hardware terminal and now also means back end databases. At the time I wasn't aware of either
JB in your older WS you don't say about the knowledge of SPMs

IH I apologise for not going into that level of detail, but that's what I recall he told me.
JB in your Inquiry WS you mention the keystroke element, you don't in the trial WS
IH no I didn't go deep into the tech detail
JB have you later learned this
IH no I do recall that…

… the exact way getting into a branch was described to me by GJ in Sep 2012
JB was GJ being quite open with you about Fujitsu (F)'s capability to affect and change branch accounts
IH yes the only deficiency was on my part in a failure to ask more q's

IH.. I didn't know he'd been an expert witness by that stage
JB do you think he appreciated his responsibility re the courts
IH no don't think so – he was a tech person
JB did he tell you about bugs in that Sep 2012 meeting
IH the preferred term tended to be anomaly or error

… didn't explore it much but he offered to send me various reports
IH did alwen lyons and Lesley Sewell say they would look into what GJ said?
JB no – I was told in terms there was no problem and there had been reports concluding this
IH did you raise this with them – that…

… they were contradicting the chief architect of H
JB no I took it as a conflict of evidence and reported it back to Ron

JB you formed a view this had an impact on reliability of prosecutions
IH yes – it was quite difficult to deal with as the PO were clear I was completely mistaken
JB why did you think you might be sacked if you made it an issue
IH ferocity of response made me realise…

… this was a big issue. Made clear to me the PO would not welcome it being pursued Discussed it with Ron and we decided to file it away, see what cooperation we could get and carry on

JB takes him to a F note of a teleconference
JB so this workshop discussed was part of setting up your meeting with GJ

JB so F are suggesting you should get xml data
IH yes
JB so F and GJ were being helpful
IH yes but also commercial – they explained there was a cost attached to getting hold of ARQ data and the PO was not keen to pay for it

JB your view of GJ
IH v helpful throughout
JB takes him to a call RW recorded possibly in Sep 2012

This is the mention of GJ

concludes
JB so GJ was being helpful
IH yes
JB more so than the PO
IH yes

[specifically – JB he was willing to discuss remote access when the PO was not – IH yes]
JB takes him to another call transcript

More 2S love for GJ

JB so he seemed candid and open where the PO was not
IH yes just a sense we got that he was talking technical things and unemcumbered by political considerations

[we're on our second break – former SPM Wendy Buffrey and C5 news chief corr Tessa Chapman have just come up to say hello, which is nice. During first break had a quick chat with Ron Warmington and his wife Helen, who are sitting at the front listening to IH's evidence]

[The BBC's Emma Simpson is tapping away furiously next to me, the BBC's Andy Verity was parked behind me and Alex Thomson from C4 news is over at the press benches on the other side of the room with his producer Nanette]

[thrilling info, huh? I'm going to take a break from typing as my shoulder muscles are really starting to ache – goodness knows how the inquiry stenographer copes with all this]

[we're back]
JB in your WS at par 30 you say the agreed goal at the outset of your investigations between 2S and the PO – was that the shared goal
IH more by James Arbuthnot and the MPs which the PO agreed to at the outset
JB you tell us in your WS at par 45 where you sought to

… query the safety of crim convictions -and the PO rebuffed it – how does that square with a desire to get to the bottom of things
IH this comes from the PO's attitude towards us as non crim law experts which we shared, we were experts in evidence, and we raised probs with…

… evidence which they should then pursue.
JB takes him to PO GC Chris Aujard's threat to him

JB what were the circs of this threat
IH just that it was after a working group meeting – he came across as an ambitious and aggressive lawyer and that came through in the way he dealt with us. He didn't like the things we said in some of the meetings

… and I thought what he said was inappropriate
JB what happened to the shared desire to find the truth no matter of the consequences
IH i think we'd moved on from that [laughter in the room]

… quite early on in the process the PO was getting advice from lawyers on what we were uncovering and they were telling them about the likely compensation they might be in for – and that worried them as a potential existential threat.
I did a back of a fag packet…

… calculation and I thought the PO was looking at £300m compensation to the mediation scheme applicants. They were very worried about this and the PR fallout for them. PR was driving a lot of this
JB how do you know that
IH from contact with Mark Davies the

… director of communications. PO senior management were concerned about brand image etc PV was very open about it
JB when did this become evident to you
IH when we were identified as a potential threat to the PO business model

JB takes him to par 68 in his WS
JB what was PV doing to steer you away from safety of convictions

IH don't remember precisely but in MS working group she didn't want crim cases even going to the working group, but PO didn't want to support crim cases in mediation

More from the WS

… about PV

JB asks again what PV did to steer him away
IH we had relatively little direct contact with PV – through her, AvdB and their actions there was clearly a problem with the mediation of crim convictions

JB takes him to IH's regrets and reporting lines to the PO feature – did you address the board
IH no not till we spoke to Tim Parker in Dec 2015 after we were sacked. It was a mistake for PO and for us and we should have insisted on it.
JB raises par 160…

… and asks him what he intended to blow the whistle on
IH as our work progressed we were coming across potential miscarrs and when we raised them we were threatened – there should be an option for contractors to blow the whistle outside their NDAs

JB takes him to his WS pars 161 and 162 and raises an email in connection with it

It's written by RW to IH and cc's James Arbuthnot's chief of staff Janet Walker
JB do you agree with what RW wrote here?
IH yes I do

[JB's questions end here]

[Now questions from Sam Stein KC for a group of SPMs about suspense accounts]
SS this is an area of interest to our clients
IH I think we have a mutual interest here – I think asking about suspense accounts is why we got sacked

SS takes him to this email – why did you ask this q
IH PO was not printing money – the money they handled either belonged to clients or SPMs and I wanted to get to the bottom of it

SS takes him to Andy Parsons (AP)'s response to his colleagues

And what AP proposed sending back to IH

SS this response was never sent to you, but do you think this assertion was correct
IH it may have been, it may not have been. I felt the most likely explanation was that those suspense account balances were connected with losses being allocated to SPMs
SS would looking at the..

… suspense accounts tell you how healthy the H system was?
IH possibly but sus accounts are a feature of modern accounting and most suspense accounts are resolved in a few days – but in the PO these sums are being held for more than six months which is very poor…

… accounting practice.
SS if these amounts are not put into P&L where is the money going
IH properly investigated and resolved, with money if nec going back to the SPMs
SS but if it stayed in P&L
IH it would go into profits and dividends

SS takes him to the Crowe response

And Rodric Williams' response

SS so the PO want to give away as little as possible, but if they do they want MI data from 3 to 5 years. Would that answer your q
IH no – we wanted to know about breakdown of sus accounts into individual transactions and branches and I'm not sure this would do it

IH it's a cover-up… again.
SS takes him to an email from Chris Aujard to Alisdair Cameron (PO CFO)

SWW wants to know if IH got a written response on sus accounts
IH not that we saw

[Okay this is the Aujard to Cameron email]
SS can you help us with your view on what's going on here
IH CA had protection of PO at the centre of his activity. AC was the newly appointed finance director who perhaps shared our view that we'd asked an interesting q

… but that was resisted by the legal team at the PO
SS where were we by this stage – did you ever get an answer
IH no there was a concern that money had been taken from SPMs and it should have been investigated
[SS ends and JB takes up one more line of q with IH again]

JB takes IH to the First Clarke Advice on Gareth Jenkins (GJ) from 15 July – when did you first see this
IH only recently
JB you say you were reliant on GJ for info, but you didn't know he was an expert witnest
IH correct
JB you were looking at files on the Misra case
IH yes

JB do you think you should have been showed the Clarke Advice
IH when I was looking at the files I thought I was looking at everything – so yes
JB you were raising concerns about poss micarrs
IH yes

JB and you were not told about the Clarke Advice or the substance of it
IH correct
SWW where did you get the info in your IR about bugs from

IH the PO's Simon Baker gave it to us quite late before publication – 2 or 3 types of bug we were previously unaware of.
SWW orally or a doc
IH both – telephone contact and doc
[IH's evidence concludes. Ron Warmington (RW) after lunch]

[Ron Warmington has been sworn in. He is just going through the usual WS corrections and confirmations]

JB going through his career – Global Head of Investigations at Citibank, Director of GE Capital and then set up Second Sight – so when appointed by the PO you were an independent forensic accountant set up to look broadly at Horizon (H)
RW yes

JB you had the backing of MPs
RW yes
JB in the course of your work you had access to senior people within the PO who could access info about H and disciplinary action taken against SPMs
RW correct

JB you initially received clear promises of access to all docs from Susan Crichton, Alice Perkins and Paula Vennells
RW yes

JB despite this the PO reneged on those promises by withholding docs and proper answers
RW yes
JB and eventually formed the view 2S was under their control and could do what the PO wanted
RW yes, their view
JB the PO denied probs they knew of
RW yes

JB and tried to deny issues
RW yes
JB why did they do this?
RW the PO knew that they were dealing with an existential issue. If H was generating spurious shortfalls, that they had a lousy investigation function, that they had wrongfully prosecuted people – that was existential

JB in what way
RW to have it known H was unreliable would mean all hell would break loose in the branch network
JB did you form this view during your work
RW right from the outset. I warned PO top brass of this from day zero

JB when did the PO start to renege on their promises –
RW prob around Feb 2013
JB the inquiry has seen a number of docs which show that in 2013 individuals within the PO contemplating limiting or ending your involvement – were they ever cooperating
RW yes. from the start…

… SC and Simon Baker appeared to want to assist us
JB what changed
RW when they started lawyering up
JB what caused that –
RW when IH started finding really odd stuff in the legal files
JB what odd stuff
RW the Brander report for one – it suggested wholly inadequate…

… investigation work.
JB a regular crit of your work was the slow pace at which it was proceedings – was that expressed to you
RW yes
JB was it true

RW yes – we had lots of applicant cases and there were long delays getting info and paperwork from the PO
JB what about before the mediation scheme
RW part of getting info out of a siloed org was tricky – it was like swimming up a waterfall…

… getting the data to us so we could reach any conclusions was taking an inordinate amount of time.

JB goes to a WS

RW's WS in fact…. the PO's "ferocious" and "monstrous" pushback.
JB you gave us the Rudkin eg here – what else?
RW it was constant – mainly around unevidenced remarks we were making eg not receiving a contract before being appointed – and PO would say…

… you're just spouting unevidenced anecdotal evidence – so I went back to them and said I have yet to see a signed postmaster contract and they would say the PO "would have" done things. At first I was taken in by it

JB what do you mean – taken in?
RW I thought I'd lost the knack of explaining things properly, but then I realised they were feigning ignorance and stupidity in order to be unhelpful

JB did you adapt the words used in your CRRs as a result of the PO's challenge
RW sometimes, there were pretty intense scraps and tried to listen to where they pushing back, and certainly where we made mistakes we'd correct them
JB IH says PO did not try to influence…

… your reports other than by withholding documents – you say they did
RW yes I think I got more resistance in doing what I was doing
JB what was the division of labour
RW IH worked at the PO whereas I went round the country dealing with SPM cases

JB takes him to his WS par 58 re the 2S IR

Par 58 ends…

JB takes him to the IR and notes this point about work still needing to be done – what work still needed to be done.
RW [gets confused between job one and job two – Jason Beer takes him to his WS]

RW attempts to explain what was going on
JB summarises – that there were two pieces of work Job 1 and Job 2 – the first was going to focus on systemic or system-wide issues with h
RW job 1 was very broad but IR was not an attempt to answer questions by MPs, but it was just on…

… narrow issues. We should probably have refused.
JB who asked for that
RW the PO
JB why not refuse
RW the MPs were getting keen for us to produce a report which said something so this narrow request was agreed on
JB after the IR what was still left?

RW had we not been distracted by the Mediation Scheme we would have addressed the issues in my initial proposal
JB the PO wanted that to stop and set up the mediation scheme – did you support that
RW yes – we though getting cases in and through the door would be good

JB your conclusion about system-wide problems with the H software – how many cases had you looked at before getting to that conclusion
RW 49 – we couldn't investigate ALL cases, we came up with spot reviews where we looked at events within the cases
JB so your conclusion…

… was based on the four spot reviews
RW we'd looked at more but those four were the ones we looked at and they included the Rudkin case which wasn't even bottomed out
JB should you have been clearer about what you meant about system-wide
RW in hindsight yes

RW the PO jumped on the phrase and Alan Bates warned us they would – he's pretty astute – he saw a draft and said this was what they'd do
JB takes him to a recording of a call RW made with Tim McCormack

This was recorded a year and a half on from the IR.
JB why avoid systemic errors when you tell Tim M that there were systemic errors
RW we found errors which were manifesting themselves unusually, they were rare…

… but they had life-changing effects for the people they impacted. In terms of their wider consequences they were miniscule. I'm being muddle-headed here still. I wish we'd never used the word "systemic" it was wrong and widely abused.

JB goes back to RW's WS and raises prosecutorial misconduct

Goes to par 16.
JB Did PV tell you it wasn't part of 2S's brief not to look for evidence.
RW it's a matter of regret we had far less contact with PV than we should have. We were shunted down to the execs who said they were conduits for PV's wishes

JB takes him to PV's initial reaction to 2S's proposals.
[very positive!]
JB does this fairly reflect your initial meeting with her
RW – yes it's abbreviated
JB in what way –

RW it's the meeting I laid it on the line that this was a high risk venture for her and I might not be the right choice
JB did you get any feedback on the powerpoint presentation
RW no – it was quite weird, we thought it would be a small job. we never got a letter of engagement

… which we would have insisted on today. We just got the go-ahead.
JB after the meeting with PV did you believe she meant what she said – the PO's objective was being transparent and dealing with your outcomes and conclusions
RW yes

JB why did the PO appoint 2S
RW we were cheap – fewer overheads and less greed – we had a good vfm proposition. I think SC – with whom I'd never played tennis – knew I had form for presuming innocence

JB was that in Citi or GE Capital
RW Citi – looking into conduct of all employees at all levels

JB takes him to his WS with concerns about the way 2S were contracted – why?
RW having the PO as the paymaster and subject of the investigation was daft
JB was having the treasury pay for it at that point an option
RW Oliver Letwin said it was out of the question

… but they could have done it.

JB you had to expand your work. you say you had no trouble doing so
RW correct
JB one was Chris Hollyoake – he joined you around Feb 2014
RW yes
JB Kim Evans in July 2014
RW yes
JB Niall Young – August 2014

JB so for the time up until the IR there were the three of you [??! three? two surely]
RW yes
JB did you think about bolstering your team before getting the IR out
RW it might have slowed us down as we'd have to onboard them

JB did the rise in the number of cases between Summer 2012 and 2013 cause resourcing problems
RW yes
JB you said the lack of a central file was a surprise
RW yes
JB what were you expecting to find

RW as a general investigator when we had to deal with ATM fraud or customer fraud the investigators would on a case management system pull together all the cases and all the key elements of it – the PO had none of that
JB this might be a noddy question but why would you expect

… a firm to pull together the complaints made by its SPMs
RW it's hard to see how you can provide a functioning investigation service to its employer
JB you're referring to an electronic compendium of letters from customers, reports from line managers, court judgments whether

… for or against. Media reports. Letters to the Sunday Times etc
RW yes
JB what about matters coming up through the helpdesk via Fujitsu or PO helpdesk
RW yes
JB would this include misbalancing reports, or bugs errors or defects

JB were you ever made aware there had been acquittals in crim trials of SPMs who alleged H errors
RW no
JB was Nichola Arch, Susan Palmer or Maureen McElvey ever mentioned to you
RW no not at that stage

JB did the PO tell you about docs dealing with H problems – bug fixes, service management reports etc
RW no
JB did the PO give you Jason Coyne's report into the Cleveley's case
RW no i wish they had
JB the BDO report into the Castleton case
RW no
JB PINICLs PEAKs and KELs?
RW no

JB did you ask anyone at PO where their general file was?
RW yes – SC was as exasperated as I was that there was no general file

JB takes him to a report by RW from possibly early 2013 to SC – because SC had been asked to take over John Scott's department

It goes on
JB point 1 – did you get that from interview transcripts and reports
RW yes

JB reads on

… and more

JB this was headed up as draft – was it ever finalised
RW no – it was done as an aside so I never finalised it, but I stand by everything in it
JB let's look at what happened to this report…

JB takes RW to a letter from the CCRC to Rod Williams
JB where's this from
RW probably from a meeting I had with the CCRC in Birmingham at their request
JB reads from it and carefully checks that what RW is reported as saying is totally accurate

RW agrees
JB why was it sent to Aujard
RW I recall it being mentioned at a working group meeting and IH and I were surprised that SC had not given it to CA
JB was anything done about your recommendations second time around?
RW not to my knowledge

[we are on a break until 3.20pm]
Here is a picture of Ian Henderson giving C4 News an interview in the Inquiry ante-room within minutes of his evidence finishing this lunchtime. Note BBC's Emma Simpson in the background preparing for her One O'Clock News live

[Just spoken to one of the SPM claimants at the Inquiry today. Apparently there's a hearing at the Rolls building between DBT and the Insolvency practictioner about an aspect of some of the bankrupt cases. The SPM asked me where they will publish the transcript of the hearing..

… when I explained he'd have to apply to both parties etc etc – he was surprised. The world has moved on – why can't all Old Bailey and High/CoA/Supreme Court hearings be transcribed and published as with Hansard – that would be open justice]

[anyway the break is over. RW has around 70 more mins giving evidence]

JB takes RW to his WS par 46
RW goes to SC about his concerns about prosecutorial misconduct

JB so this was a face to face meeting, was it
RW yes
JB just you and SC present
RW yes
JB so you raised the issues re prosecutorial misconduct IH thought he'd seen
RW yes
JB what was the prosecutorial misconduct

RW the improper chasing of assets and IH's view and the failure to disclose exculpatory evidence. I still have less experience than Ian on matters like this but it was pretty compelling to me so I shared those views with Susan

JB did any of the five things you mentioned in that draft document to SC come up
RW yes probably all of them, but in rather coarse language
JB what did you say needed to happen
RW I said don't rely on us – you need to confirm or rubbish what we said and if an expert in crim law

… believes we're right you're going to have to reexamine more cases. If we're wrong then come back to us and tell us
JB why is none of this in your IR
RW the IR was produced in order to come out with something which evidenced the working that had gone on and was going on…

… and on which we hadn't yet concluded a view. Some our unconcluded thoughts could have been dumped out in the report, but it wasn't

JB you say SC said she'd take it to Cartwright King and you laughed out loud because CK would be marking their own homework
RW yes
JB reads from par 47

JB notes Ron's expletive has been caught by "our data protection machine" – there is laughter in court
RW unfortunately
JB this is very serious isn't it
RW yes it was the central issue
JB did you find out by Autumn 2012 whether this did go to a competent legal firm or CK…

… ?
RW no I don't know
JB and when action was taken later do you know if it was sparked by your suggestion or the Clarke Advice
RW no they didn't tell me anything – perhaps should have pursued it more vigourously and what was going on with this

JB takes him to the email we saw this morning with Simon Baker asking RW to agree to something PV wants 2S to agree to

JB can you see that pt 2 is asking you to link to separate things
RW it was asking us to agree to do something ludicrous
JB I think now you say you'd say no, but let's look at your response at the time

JB IH had told you about prosecutorial misconduct – you'd told SC about pm – why do you not mention it here
RW I couldn't quite work out why I worded this email this way – I'm hovering around the thought I was being facetious – I was so irritated by the daft question…

… I gave a daft answer. The question was patently absurd. I wish now I'd given them both barrels with the suspicion that there were wrongful prosecutions.
JB yes you could have said "I informed SC about this – we said then…

…. we weren't experts and they needed to get independent advice"…
RW … and that was ongoing… and I guess we still trusted that this was happening and we were expecting feedback on this

JB takes RW to the second part of par 106 of his WS of his assessment of GJ
JB did you form that view contemporaneously
RW I find it hard to believe we were as prescient as we were…

… – but IH has served as an WS and how they have to conduct themselves and the form and format of their reports – and we knew that GJ was partisan and wondered how GJ could be an expert witness. He came across as an expert. We would not have told SC that GJ would be a good EW

JB were you made aware of the Simon Clarke advice in 2013 – 2015
RW no
JB when did you become aware of the existence of the document
RW during the CoA hearings
JB in Nov 2020
RW yes

JB told of the substance of the Clarke Advice
RW no
JB in Autumn 2013 the PO lawyers knew there was an issue with GJ – was that revealed to you
RW no

JB did you know GJ had been used as an expert in court proceedings
RW yes when I started looking at Misra et al's individual cases
JB did you know GJ had been used in 15 cases but had not been instructed – would that have caused concern
RW no they didn't and yes it would

JB more concerns about the fitness of PO prosecutions
RW yes
JB what if it had been revealed
RW it would have heightened our suspicions it was a complete and utter mess
JB did you review the Misra file
RW came to it after Ian and reviewed it on CD1

JB was that the disclosed docs to the defence or the complete prosecution file
RW don't know

JB goes to RW's concluding thoughts – refused to be contracted to the company you were investigating
RW yes
JB wish you had demanded to see PV more
RW yes
JB and to address the full board
RW yes
JB did you ever get to address the board
RW no save the Dec 2015 meeting with TIm…

… Parker
JB did you ask
RW no. wish i had
JB you say you wish you had refused to communicate through Chris A, Patrick B, AvdB and Belind Crowe – were they the four?
RW yes plus Rodric W and Jane McLeod
JB why do you wish you hadn't used them as conduits

RW it was awful – they were not just failing to understand everything they said, they were part of a cabal conspiring to thwart us. We were talking to the monkeys not the organ-grinder and I feel ashamed that I fell into that trap

JB takes him to a transcript of a call RW recorded

JB takes him to the relevant pars

and more…

JB was AJ an SPM
RW yes
JB reads "I've never come across anything as bad as this"
JB is that an accurate view of your engagement
RW that's exactly how I felt then and how I feel now
SWW what year was that
RW I'd say Aug 2014
SWW so in the context of the Mediation Scheme
RW yes

[JB qs ends. SS KC picks up]
SS did you find out if Fujitsu had a general file
RW should have asked that. didn't
SS you had to sign an NDA with the PO – you then offered your assistance to Freeths but your NDA prevented that
RW we met Patrick Green and later

… Dr Worden and Jason Coyne when we were helping them with their combined WS
SS if you didn't have the NDA would that have helped your ability to help with the GLO
RW oh yes

SS talking of dedication – Ms Linnell has provided unstinting report to the JFSA
RW [gives very fulsome tribute to Kay Linnell and her work] …. she is one of the few who isn't sitting in the car of the Horizon gravy train…"

SS takes him to Suspense Accounts

This looks like it's addressed in RW's 2nd WS

[there is a long disco with SS about suspense accounts and the PO's initial refusal to recognise to SS that they existed all the way through to the PO's failure to deal with them properly and the sums involved]

RW were concerned solely with the items which remained unresolved that found their way into the PO's P&L account. It was concerning to say there was the possibility – I would say a certainty that there were amounts in that Suspense account that should have been returned to SPMs

SS to date has this been resolved
RW simple answer is no – in inquiry material I have seen docs from KPMG as late as 2020 that things now are okay. But they didn't go back to the specific items we raised with the PO from the 136 examples in the MS that we brough to the CFO…

… were not reviewed.

[sorry we've had some tech issues – computer ran out of memory and crashed so I've missed all of Flora Page's questions. RW began to enjoy himself and was playing to the gallery a bit]

Flora Page takes RW to the report he mentioned by KPMG

And is asked about the caveats
FP were they let off the leash
RW don't think they were – they didn't look at the obvious lines of inquiry IH came up with
FP this report should not be relied on for any purpose
RW yeah this is "we're just going to ask some questions…

… and believe what we're told" – not that I'm criticising KPMG who are bigger than us and can beat us up
[laughter]

FP asks if H is a double-entry book-keeping system
RW I'm not sure that assertion is true [gives example of Jo Hamilton's doubled transaction] – the system invented money at that moment
FP asks about bolted on system – did that cause extra problems

RW I go back to my training in 1966 – you can't assert block entries are double-entry…
SWW has some qs
SWW some of the senior PO execs at this inquiry denied the mediation scheme was a sham – who came up with the idea
RW SC
SWW was it being operated in good faith

RW not from the outset – it looked like a legitimate exercise until we realised it wasn't – it was much later we learned about token payments. Sir Alan realised it was a scam much quicker
SWW so for much of the time you thought it was being operated in good faith…

… but when we started getting the POIRs back and none of them gave an inch we realised they were being structured in this way…
SWW so when did it turn
RW prob by year end 2013
SWW two issues one was the expectation gap – what the SPMs thought would be their comp and

… and the fact some wouldn't be mediated at all.
RW it was obvious to us the driving force was James Arbuthnot's meeting with Alice Perkins and its crazy that JA would say yeah sure exclude Jo Hamilton…

… on the expectation gap – when we saw the CQR claims from the applicants with the numbers attached it didn't surprise me or Ian – it was only when we realised the PO had no intention of paying anything like a realistic amounts…

… they never said that to us – if they had we would have asked what they were smoking
[laughter in the room]
SWW what were the other problems
RW the lawyering up – that was the problem – I think the lawyers took all potential liability out – they removed all admissions of…

… failure, let alone guilt.
SWW thanks RW and that is the end of RW's evidence. we return tomorrow at 0945 to hear from two former big deals at Fujitsu (more details here: www.postofficehorizoninquiry.org.uk/phase-5-and-6-timetable

My publishers are going for a drink with Ron and Ian and part of me is tempted to join them rather than write today up for the website.

well, let's see what happens.

thanks for reading all these tweets.

Live Tweet Archives

  • ▼2026 (4)
  • ►2024 (47)
  • ►2023 (8)
  • ►2022 (14)