Sir Stephen Lovegrove – former ShEx CEO

Remote live tweets from Day 164 of the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry.

178 tweets

Good afternoon – I'm covering day 164 of the Post Office Horizon IT remotely. I'll live tweet it for those who cannot watch it live here:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=oQCsFNNOqds

Today's evidence comes from former Shareholder Executive official Sir Stephen Lovegrove (SL). Before he takes the oath, the inquiry chair Sir Wyn Williams (SWW) has announced a research project relevant to the 7th and final stage of the inquiry…

He says:
"The final phase of the inquiry, phase seven, is concerned essentially with the here and now. I will be inquiring into such questions as how does the post office treat its postmasters, sub-postmasters, what is the culture of the post office like now? …

… How does that culture compare with the culture prevailing before the group litigation? How do those who are entitled to compensation view their experiences of making claims? Has the post office and government delivered on its promise to provide compensation which is full and fair?…

… In order to help me answer these questions, I have commissioned YouGov, an independent research and data analytics firm, to conduct two surveys. One survey is aimed at current sub-postmasters. The second survey is for those who have applied for compensation under the horizon shortfall scheme…

… I want to hear from all of those persons to whom these surveys will be sent. As people with direct experience of the topics covered by the surveys, are best placed to provide me with invaluable information…

… about key issues relating to current practices within the post office and how the largest compensation scheme has operated in practice. To current sub-postmasters, let me make one thing clear…

… I know full well it can be difficult to speak about the challenges you have faced, or still face at work, or in your claims for compensation. Let me assure you that these surveys are in no way connected to the post office. They are anonymous…

… and no individual will be identified. identified when the findings are published. Some of the applicants to the horizon shortfall scheme will have negotiated compensation payments with post office on a without prejudice basis…

… I am pleased to be able to report that post office has agreed to waive the legal privilege which attaches to such negotiations specifically for these surveys. This means that those applicants who conducted negotiations…

… on a without prejudice basis can share their experiences when responding to the surveys without fear of repercussions. I want to make public, too, that post office at the inquiry's request will shortly…

… be writing to all applicants to the historic shortfall scheme inviting them to waive their legal privilege in respect of certain information about the scheme. The post office is taking that step so…

… as to enable it to answer requests for information which the inquiry has requested it should provide. I urge all applicants to the scheme to respond positively to this letter…

… so the inquiry is given as much information as possible on how the scheme is running. The answers which are provided to the surveys will be treated as formal evidence to the inquiry…

… and they will be analyzed by you gov in a report. Such a report will, I have no doubt, help to make sure valuable lessons can be learned. From this week, some 16,000 people will be contacted directly via email…

… The surveys can be completed online or over the telephone for those who need reasonable adjustments…

… If you are both a current Subpostmaster and you applied for compensation under the horizon shortfall scheme, you will receive two separate survey links…

… , one for each survey. Let me conclude by saying this. Human stories are at the heart of this inquiry. As will be obvious by now, and as I have said from time to time…

… , I have been deeply affected by the accounts of the hardship and suffering endured by many. I urge all those who are contacted to complete the surveys, and I offer my heartfelt thanks now to all"

If you're wondering how I have managed to get that down verbatim, I am experimenting with some real-time AI powered transcription. Going forward in this thread, NOTHING I write is a direct quote unless it is in "direct quotes"

Lovegrove has taken the oath, his witness statement (WS) has been sworn into evidence and…

… Inquiry barrister Emma Price (EP) is asking the questions.

Lovegrove worked for investment banker Morgan Grenfell in its media team from 1993 to 2003 and from there went straight to the government's Shareholder Executive (ShEx or SE) which looks after the govt's companies including RMG and the Post Office. SE calls these Arm's Length…

… Bodies (ALBs) or "assets". Lovegrove started working for companies "owned" by the DMCS, but then got into the Post Office (PO) in 2005.

Became CEO of SE in 2007 (fast rise!) and went on to become Perm Sec at Dept for Environment and then MoD.

Continued to rise to become the National Security Advisor and then PM's advisor on Defence Strategy.

SL's WS says SE was to be an "effective and intelligent shareholder"
EP what was required to ensure that the government was an effective and intelligent shareholder?

SL "a clear and well-articulated set of policy objectives for the companies in question… a clear and well-articulated set of objectives, commercial objectives"

SL also, and to the extent where that we possibly could, we wanted to ensure that the corporate apparatus and the corporate governance of the assets for which we were responsible as nearly approximated best practice in the private sector as we could

EP why ALBs?
SL Because the assets, managed mainly actually, within central Whitehall would have led to very, very inefficient. practices, Whitehall, so we would set up a, or typically there would be an organisation set up at

SL arm's length from government in order to be able to recruit the right people to do that

EP "paragraph 31 of your statement that the types of decisions that were for ALBs to take, rather than ShEX or the government, would include matters which are sometimes described as 'operational' or 'contractual'…

EP "… But you say that in your view this terminology does not always help to distinguish between those matters in which government became involved. and those in which it did not. Is that right?"

SL "That is correct."
EP "You also make clear that the government had a role in establishing policy goals and monitoring operational performance. So, in short, it would not just set the strategy for an asset and leave it to it."
SL "Correct"

SL "… I mean the strategy for an asset would be set in cooperation with the executives and board of the asset. In most instances and we would use much of the management information that the executives and the..

… board of the asset were using to run the company to assist us in our own oversight of the asset."

EP "Can you help at all with what, if any, training was given to ShEx employees about the circumstances in which operational or contractual matters might be relevant to… policy or strategic considerations?"

SL "I'm not sure that the in the precise terms in which you talk about it we had specific training like that. There would certainly be an induction period when a civil would find…

… themselves being assigned to a particular asset, they would learn about it, they would learn about the policy objectives, they would learn about the commercial objectives…

… they would learn about the assets in general and clearly there were plenty of people in shareholder executive certainly towards the end who had experience of helping people through."

EP: "Do you believe that SCEC's employees understood that the distinction between operations and strategy or policy was not always clear-cut?"

[sorry that should say ShEx not SCEC]

SL: "Yes, I mean there was a very fuzzy line between these things. sometimes, and that continues to be in every organisation I've ever been involved in."

SL "The shareholder executive was aiming to bring a distinctive capability to government, which did not exist before 2003-2004, which was that there was a level of commercial professional expertise in overseeing these assets….

SL "… So on the whole, what we would try to do would be to look at both the policy function and the commercial function in a way that had not happened before where civil servants, policy civil servants, would typically really just look at the policy function….

… That gave quite a lot of latitude to the boards of the ALBs who were then effectively allowed to run the commercial functions as they saw fit, and it was attempting to redress that kind of balance for which shareholder executive was set up…

… On the whole, we wanted policy objectives, though, to be set. Discussed with ministers who ultimately set those policy objectives by policy officials because…

… it was not for us to decide for instance whether or not the purposes of Channel 4 were going to be met by shareholder executive oversight or indeed the purposes of the post office…

… were going to be discharged by a purely commercial approach. So we wanted on the whole where we could to get the policy objectives out of shareholder executive. We weren't always successful with that and we weren't totally successful on Royal Mail and post office."

EP takes SL to par 40 of his WS

… reads it all out

EP did you come across this resistance at the PO
SL no – i saw it at RMG, but not at the PO – that I saw myself
EP did you come across the PO being resistant to sharing info with the board and govt
SL there clearly was a degree of reluctance for Susannah Storey from ShEX…

… joining the PO board and that might speak to what you're talking about.

EP brings up a doc from Dec 2006 which SL wrote to the Sec of State

It focuses on Royal Mail Group (RMG) – of which Post Office ltd was a subsidiary.

[A company at war with its shareholder, apparently…]

EP co "indulging in gaming"?
SL being slow to provide info, using the media to get a POV across which might be better shared privately, generally not having a straightforward relationship we aspired to have

EP what did you do about this?
SL have some rather difficult convos with members of the board. I wouldn't want to say this was a broken relatinoship because everyone was at each other's throats. This was a business in extremely challenging circs…

… we needed to make a large investment in it to keep it solvent…

… the context was that this was quite a fraught environment… the relationships got better, but it was a fraught relationship at the time and we had to work hard to ensure ministers' objectives were fulfilled.

EP "resentment manifesting itself in the company refusing… to provide info" was this about commercially sensitive info?
SL yes – this is RMG, tho, not PO

EP you say RMG's culture of independence carried over into PO and the PO chair resisted a ShEx NED – what was the reason for this
SL that Alice Perkins (PO chair) was pretty clear about her objections – potential for conflict of interest…

EP what did you think the reasons were
SL a desire for independence from govt to the extent it was manageable
EP was a resistance to info sharing something carried over from RMG
SL dunno

SL … wasn't close enough to it
EP takes him to his WS par 68

… she reads it and reads onto par 69
EP did you take steps to get a NED on the board of RMG before separation?
SL no

EP was the "strong pushback" and potential resignation of the chair was ever discussed with RMG
SL so these things in par 69 were in your consideration, but was not actually discussed with RMG
EP correct, probably

[we go to a spreadsheet – SE quarterly report into its portfolio]

Goes to RMG

[this is an active doc and EP is clicking in and out of the boxes and reading them out]

EP from this doc – the relationship with the board was poor
SL certainly problematic – not been successful in resetting the relationship
EP why
SL difficult if chair and board have set their face against them – if chair does not want to do a board review, it's hard to do it

EP was fear that insufficient info being shared with SE
SL probably – we probably wanted to see more
EP what concerns about strength of RMG execs
SL we felt we had a strong CEO and FD, I can't remember at this distance…

EP let me help, box 3.4 "major concerns about bench strength of team."
SL accepts that was likely what SE was told by CEO

And here is an entreaty to join the secret emailers whose subscriptions allow me to cover the Inquiry and power my website, which had a mini-scoop last week with the announcement of Nick Read (PO CEO) stepping aside. www.postofficescandal.uk/donate/

Running the website costs actual time and money and is done with the assistance of Andrew of the Dark Arts. Andrew has, this weekend, updated the front page of the website to make it look more newsy and attractive, so do have a scoot around:

www.postofficescandal.uk

You can also sign up to receive each new blog post for free via the website widget. You won't get the newsletter (which is a bit more gossipy than the website), but you'll get stuff I find time to put on the blog.

The website does have archive newsletters if you want to read them – Andrew puts them up to read for free when they are around six months old.
www.postofficescandal.uk/newsletter-archive/

eg the most recent one posted covers the suspension of the then PO's Director of Comms, Richard Taylor.

As I say this is only possible thanks to the donations of interested people, for which I remain very grateful. And now, lunch….

[lunch is over – we continue with the questioning of the only witness of the day – former ShEx CEO Sir Stephen Lovegrove]

SL = lovegrove
EP = Emma Price – barrister asking qs
SWW = Sir Wyn Williams – inquiry chair
WS = Witness Statement
SPM = Subpostmasters
PO = post office

SE = ShEx =Shareholder Executive, now UKGI which looks after govt-owned companies like the PO, the Nuclear Decommissioning Authoriy, the Atomic Weapons Establishment, Sizewell C etc

EP you think recognising risk is important
SL yep
EP takes him to his WS

EP explain more
SL this issue should have been identified by the PO, internal auditors and external auditors, but SE should have been across it – they had received letters from the JFSA, there had been meetings with the PO…

… and it was not picked up on the risk register and should have been.

EP you say in your WS that the PO prosecuted people – did you know it did that as a private prosecutor rather than having statutory powers
SL I did not know the CPS was not involved

EP inquiry has been been told there were more than 800 prosecutions brought by RMG and PO between 2000 and 2015 – how could SE not be aware
SL we were never told

SL it was a fact not widely known or "noised" [ouch. that made me wince]

EP did you know that prosecutions were being made to secure confiscation orders
SL no

EP takes him to his WS

EP how come you were unaware of the allegations about the Horizon (H) system
SL I would imagine the team in charge would have taken account of forceful, repeated and detailed denials from the PO that there was anything wrong – supported by the PO trades union [the NFSP]

EP you refer to the SE handbook [she takes him to the section on company behaviour which came up last week – this is from 2007]

EP during the time you were at SE – SE did not know about important stuff including H bugs, that a joint expert report had questioned whether H was robust leading to a court settlement and that Fujitsu (F) could access SPMs terminals without knowledge or consent.

EP taken together with the lack of knowledge you had about prosecutions – to what extent did the PO comply with the expectations in the SE handbook
SL the way you describe this – there were serious failings in this area, but by and large SE was engaging less with…

… the people close to the issues you are describing and more with the board. And it's not clear the PO board knew the things you've just described. Where teh comms breakdown actually occurs is an interesting question.

EP is it right the IT risk and the prosecution risk were separate – neither of which were identified or "socialised" with ShEx
SL yes

EP takes SL to prep note made for Ed Davey's meeting with Alan Bates

EP accepting you are unlikely to have seen this at the time let's have a look at it [EP reads the Purpose section]

Then she reads on…

"We then recommended offering a meeting in response to this 2nd request for presentational reasons"

EP reads out "our objectives"

EP reads on

[this is a really significant doc – first meeting between JFSA and a minister and than minister is currently leader of the Lib Dems, being questioned at the Inquiry this week!]

EP ends on this page…

EP this doc shows that by Oct 2010 SE and the minister were aware of allegations of endemic flaws in H and 100s of people had been prosecuted on H data
SL yes
EP yet these did not make their way on to the SE risk register before you left in 2013

EP looking at this doc, shouldn't the SE officials who produced this briefing doc should have immediately recognised this was a big risk
SL it is undeniable that this whole situation should have been on our risk register. and the PO's and RMGs… if it had been…

… it is much more likely it would be on ours.
I can't speak for my colleagues' thinking or state of mind – I can only speculate they listened to the PO and the NFSP (though I accept the JFSA didn't trust their union) and decided there was no case to answer

… and it didn't warrant escalation and that was wrong. But I speculate. Didn't write or see this doc.
EP but these were your people at SE – would you not have expected an escalation
SL I would hope it would be.

SL to be clear – it was escalated to the minister and subsequent ministers all of whom met Mr Bates

EP there is an issue here with the id and recording of risk so that the SE exec and board can be made aware of it notwithstanding the other routes a risk can have, but I repeat it should have been on the PO RR and the RMG RR

EP was there a way of governing the flow of information from assets through SE
SL yes – we knew what we wanted from assets and there would be questions if we weren't getting that info.

SL we knew what we wanted to know and we were perfectly happy to ask for it

EP takes SL to his WS describing his colleague Mike Woodhead's briefing to Ed Davey

EP dealing first with the reliance on the NFSP – were you aware the JFSA felt the NFSP had a cosy relatinoship with the NFPS
SL no I wasn't

[sorry Whitehead not Woodhead]
EP should that have made Mike Whitehead less reliant on the word of the NFSP
SL I am not sure he was… after the Oct 2010 meeting between Alan Bates and Ed Davey, MW had a long convo with the PO about the issues AB had raised…

… MW got detailed answers from the PO. The fact the NFSP were rowing in behind the PO on those issues will have been a factor, but the main info source was the PO.

EP given MW has recorded the NFSP position in his submission and his view there was a cosy relationship – should MW have been more wary of the NFSP's statements
SL yes and he may well have been

EP did SE seek assurances before relying on info provided by assets
SL no – if we did it suggested were expecting a non truthful answer. Our handbook made it clear our expectations
EP was it part of the role of SE to interrogate gaps in info before presenting it to ministers

SL yes – and we often did so – I would have a constant challenging dialogue with an asset
EP in a situation like this – wasn't there a requirement to be more probing?
SL there is evidence we were more probing as time went on – it's difficult to say they shouldn't have done more

… and that went alongside questions being asked at the PO board – ultimately leading to the appointment of Second Sight (2S) to do their review. It's open to anybody to say it should have happened quicker.

EP agree errors in the H system and prosecutions were not simply operational matters left to the PO
SL by the time the volume of those prosecution cases had reached a v high level yes I do agree, but if this had been one or two cases in a five year period I would have said…

… this was an operational matter. Capturing this when it became a systemic problem should have been done earlier.
EP given the minister was told not to meet with AB because he was asking about operational matters – was that wrong?

SL don't know as I don't know what the SE officials knew
EP well we saw that the numbers were in the hundreds – wasn't that enough to take it out of operational matters
SL I don't know – I don't know how those numbers compared to the historical prosecutions by RMG [pre H]

… I guess they would take some comfort from the fact these had gone through the British courts… I don't know. I can't give you a definitive answer.

EP takes SL to his WS
EP was achieving profitability the main focus during this period
SL it was more trying to work out whether RM was viable as a business – pension fund deficit, industrial change and unrest etc

SL we were focused on financial metrics and we had no organic sense of the operation of some of these things that we would have picked stuff up in the normal course of events. This was a stressed period indeed during RMG's history.

EP you left ShEX not long after separation of PO and RMG. Was separation a priority for the Business Department
SL it was a priority – there were others. [talks about the Hooper review – which recommended PostCom was absorbed into Ofcom, privatisation of RMG and absorbing…

… pension fund into general exchequer] so a lot of challenges
[SWW has intervened as he is chairing remotely and has lost visuals]

[there is a pause as the a/v people try to sort it]

[ten minute break to sort declared]

EP was readying RMG for privatisation and PO for separation SE priorities
SL yes
EP did RMG/PO know this
SL yes
EP would that have affected their willingness to share info with SE
SL no – the opposite

SL it's an exhausting process with enormous amounts of data reporting required to various groups
EP did you get a sense that the privatisation plan affected the appetite of SE to challenge PO on H
SL no

EP the inquiry has heard evidence about the PO's culture and conduct
SL the principle mechanism for that was through PO chair and board – corporate govt for this is ultimately in the hands of the board so our role in having an influence on PO culture would be making sure…

… it had the right kind of board.
EP were concerns about culture ethics and conduct re the PO ever raised with you at SE
SL no

EP wants to turn to PO pushback at having a SE NED on the board. The chair in SL's WS below is Alice Perkins and Anthony is Anthony Odgers

… reads on…

[there is a disco about the merits or otherwise to have a govt rep on the board of a govt-owned company]

[upshot is that overall SL is keen]
EP what mechs were there for comms with ministers
SL submissions and meetings – the job of a civil servant is often to hang round the door of ministers and try to get their ear on something – lots of formal and informal routes

EP what of your risk reviews would make their way to ministers and how
SL not sure precisely – don't think they'd get our quarterly traffic light reviews. Annual ones did and the ministers had to sign off our annual report and there was a minister who eventually had…

… responsibility for SE itself. But that was about the running of SE and not its assets
EP was the system good enough to keep ministers properly appraised.
SL impossible to say they were fully adequate. They have got better over time.

SL but if they were fully adequate they would have spotted this
EP when Susannah Storey (SS) started on the PO board was there a mechanism by which the SE NED could feed back info to SE

SL yes
EP takes SL to the beginning of the end of his WS

and par 112

EP what does this mean
SL corporate gov has evolved over time – there was a huge upheaval after the financial crash. First second and third lines were rolled out widely as business risk was not understood or implemented properly…

… looking at the evidence I have seen from the PO there were moments this could have been caught. Mainly in the risk assessments or board level at the PO. Some of this came in from the side to SE, but this is to do with implementing the best practice of corp gov as it has…

… evolved. If that were done here it would have been picked up.
EP was the PO fit for purpose
SL we did a lot leading up to separation to properly update the PO which suggests pre-separation it wasn't – there is lots to look at

EP how do you enforce proper corporate gov
SL it lies with the board – if it is the case that the correct corporate apparatus is not in place or in place and not doing its job, the chair needs to make changes with senior board members. If the chair can't or won't – then the…

… shareholder gets involved.
[talks about getting Baroness Prosser on the RMG board]
EP lines of responsibility between PO and shareholder were complex. did that run the risk that people would think other people should grip problems.
SL there was PO, RMG then govt

SL there was a good degree of oversight of the PO given it was a subsidiary of RMG, but whether or not the complications made it more difficult to pick up this… problem… I think it is a possibility. It was easier after separation.

EP goes back to par 112 "devastating effects" of gov failures. Is this a corporate gov failure or failure to adhere to good corporate gov systems
SL hard to answer

EP ends her questions – Ed Henry (EH) and Angela Fitzpatrick (AP) for two SPM groups want a crack at SL

EH it seems shareholder and gov ministers were not properly sighted on significant risk
SL risks here should have come up through the exec info going into board papers and…

… onto SE. Not clear RMG board knew of this.
EH including prosecutions
SL yes
EH your focus throughout your tenure was on RMG among other corporate responsibilities
SL yes

EH and the separation act was a big part of this
SL yes
EH you unreservedly accept the risk posed by unlawful prosecutions and debt which did not exist and it ought to have appeared on the SE RR
SL yes – the SE PO RR

EH and the SE RR
SL not sure we had an SE RR at the time, but definitely SE PO RR and SE RMG RR
EH in your WS you say you were not aware of JFSA complaints about H integrity or the Computer Weekly article – were you in a bubble of unknowing, or may you have been made aware

SL I've never read an article in CW and have no recollection
EH it was replicated in Private Eye and in govt you have media distilled and digested
SL I did not use those services
EH I have a list of CW articles on your watch. There were ten from May 2009

[EH lists the headlines]
EH none of these impacted you
SL i have no knowledge of any of those at all. I don't read publications related to the data industry or the Nuclear decommissioning industry
EH what about agitating MPs – was none of this permeating your office

SL not my office but it did permeate SE – people referring to CW, BBC progs and so on, but it was being dealt with in the way it was being dealt with – it didn't come to me.
EH the inquiry has hear from several senior RMG and PO execs – all have professed ignorance of…

… prosecutions. That's an extraordinary state of affairs.
SL I am clear there are multiple failures of corporate governance – there may be other reasons for this as well. Corp gov is part of the issue here.
EH was govt unable to appoint NEDS capable of gripping the issues or…

… is it conceivable they thought SPMs as being unworthy of their consideration.
SL any right thinking person would be horrifed by the types of stories which have come to light in the last few years… but I can't answer on specifics
EH patrick o'sullivan was taken to March 2013

… SE board meeting, but there was no mention of the risk of the prosecutions
SL there are two parts of a response to that. One is that knowledge of problems was partial, incomplete and not sufficiently escalated. If it had been, I would have been surprised…

… if the plight of the SPMs would have had any effect on the IPO of RMG. It would have been on the shoulders of PO. The RMG flotation would have lawyers all over it. If the lawyers thought it was a risk they would have raised it.

EH so the legacy of prosecutions had been hived off and left with PO?
SL was not involved in drafting the RMG prospectus, but it is very difficult to believe a floatation of that profile the legal advice would have recommended anything other than leaving reference to the…

… prosecutions on the PO.
EH that's your supposition
SL supposition, but I've done a lot of IPOs and I have yet to see anything to suggest that's not correct.
EH let us suppose between March and Oct 2013 – that surely would have dampened market confidence…

… and made the floatation a damp squib
SL doubt it
SWW sorry to interrupt – my understanding is that the prosecutions were brought by PO – but the legal facility was RMG – so the liability was PO.
EH possibly
[EH ends AP starts]

AP where you aware at the time you were responsible for RMG and PO there had been scrutiny of the contract including by the NAO
SL don't recall – does not surprise me
AP would that knowledge if you had it inform your role in oversight of RMG

SL not sure as I don't know what the NAO report
AP last week the inquiry saw an email that indicated by 2015 Baroness Neville Rolfe was asking whether or not Horizon was another govt IT debacle – would reporting IT diasters was part of public discourse in 2005?

SL it would have been, but the nature of criticisms were that they were too expensive and too slow – not remote access etc
AP but if there had been a general debate about failure and risk in contract management – would that have required better oversight of a business system…

… which was critical to an asset
SL we had no tech knowledge in house. We asked questions and took the answers at face value.
AP if you had a set of circs where you had a complex history in IT contracting, and a particular contract was that not a reason to exercise…

… particular due diligence on this contract and asset
SL did happen in the end with the arrival of 2S – whether it happened quickly enough is a matter.
AP H had a difficult history and a difficult area. Increasing body of complaints where an govt owned asset had falsely…

… prosecuted hundreds of people – required a particular sort of due diligence.
SL we did ask questions – we got forceful, diligent and repeated denials from the PO and I would take the view my officials were entitled to rely on those answers.

AP one final point re no specific tech expertise in SE. Is that kind of tech expertise is available now?
SL I would be surprised if UKGI had that tech expertise – it would be expensive to maintain and not used much, but I would expect access to independent firms UKGI could use

… to pull the drains up quickly if needed.
AP when you were in post could you or your colleagues have done it
SL yes, the info and the context at the time didn't look like it justified it – I don't think I would have expected SE to have paid for it.

AP finishes
SWW was there any RR in being when you first became CEO of SE.
SL there was not an SE RR
SWW when was a register created for SE
SL can't tell you
SWW pars 111 and 112 of your WS – although ALBs are not mentioned in those pars – is there an implicit endorsement

… of ALBs as a concept
SL yes and it's explicit in 109
SWW have you done any ALB work since 2013
SL yes many times
SWW so not an opinion just based on your SE work.
SL correct

Thanks for reading.

Live Tweet Archives

  • ▼2026 (4)
  • ►2024 (47)
  • ►2023 (8)
  • ►2022 (14)