Remote live tweets from Day 165 of the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry.
260 tweets
Good morning and welcome to the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry – day 165. Today we're going to hear from Fujitsu's Andy Dunks, who tried to mislead a High Court judge during Bates v Post Office. Live tweets follow…
#PostOfficeInquiry

Dunks has had something of a charmed life as Fujitsu's "cryptographic key manager". He did not cover himself in glory when he last gave evidence to the Inquiry, and is one of the few witnesses to be recalled. Read more here: www.postofficescandal.uk/post/why-hasnt-fujitsu-sacked-andy-dunks/
I am experimenting with some AI real-ish time transcription software so I am going to try to get more stuff down verbatim in these live-tweets than I usually manage. It might be a complete disaster and if it is I will revert to the usual method. For the avoidance of doubt…
…. NOTHING is a direct quote unless it is in "direct quotes" – some of these might be quite long direct quotes which run over several tweets. I will TRY to start each quote tweet with an open quote mark, but I may not always succeed. If in doubt…
… assume I've messed it up and wait for the official transcript tomorrow. The AI transcript is sometimes garbled and doesn't distinguish between speakers so I have to sort that out before tweeting which can make things slooooow.
If you want to support what I'm doing, please consider donating to join the secret email newsletter. It's yours for a one-off small (or large) donation. Your donation pays for me to be here and powers the Post Office Scandal website. More here:
www.postofficescandal.uk/donate/
Andrew, Master of the Dark Arts, has recently updated the front page of the website to make it look more newsy. Do have a look here:
www.postofficescandal.uk
Looks like Jason Beer KC is going to be asking the questions this morning. The witness is late.
The witness Andy Dunks (AD) is here. Sir Wyn Williams (SWW) is in the (remote) Chair and it is indeed Jason Beer KC (JB) asking the questions.
Dunks is being given the privilege against self-incrimination reminder by SWW. This indicates he is a person of interest to the Metropolitan Police who are investigating the Post Office scandal.
No one, unless I am mistaken, has exercised their right to ask to avoid answering a question at this inquiry to date.
AD being sworn in…

You can follow this of course on youtube…
www.youtube.com/watch?v=bl2rxJUrgyk
Oh – Andy Dunks has just confirmed he still employed by Fujitsu. The Inquiry previously had him listed as a former employee and I have repeated that on here and elsewhere. Apologies.
JB "You refer in your witness statement to the Post Office Accounts Prosecution Support Section, the PSS, yes?"
AD "Yes."
JB "Can you confirm that that entity, the Prosecution Support Section was not part of the post office. It was part of Fujitsu."
AD "yes"
JB "Was there anyone embedded from the post office in it"
AD "No, there wasn't"
We are looking at a Fujitsu policy document

re prosecutions…

JB is reading this…

[Am struggling to align real time document capture with the lag on the AI transcription – I might bin off trying to do "direct quotes" unless something important or quotable comes up and stick to characterisations of dialogue]
JB see this line? Was it the PO's role to agree with Fujitsu (F) Prosecution Support which lines should appear in a witness statement
AD don't know
JB you wrote many many Witness statements (WS) – how did you decide what to include
AD from the witness template

JB the WS appears to include a number of optional pars – does that reflect your understanding
AD – erm… optional? no I don't recall that
JB the inquiry has seen instructions to WS providers to include eg D, F and Q but ignore E and G
AD don't remember that
JB okay this is a draft WS

JB see how each par begins with a letter?
AD yes

JB what did you understand the capital letters were for
AD not sure I used this document or referred to it. I wasn't aware how WS's were generated
JB you drafted them
AD not the template
JB but you decided what went into your signed WS
AD no we used a template
JB right. where was the template kept
AD in a shared folder
JB in a PSS within your security team
AD yes
JB did it look like this?
AD can't remember
JB let's go back to this bit… – this did not accord, you say, with what happened in practice. You included what was on the template rather than what PO and F say should be covered in the WS
AD yes

JB would you always use the whole of the template or would you cut bits out
AD don't think so
JB so you don't remember a stage of the process where there was a filleting of the template – you just got the template out of the hard drive and signed it
AD basically yes
JB takes him further into the same doc

JB reads from the above doc…
JB never mind the detail of what this says – were you aware of the sense of it – that there was a facility for expert witness statements to be provided
AD no
JB was that language in use at the time – Mr X or Ms Y – is providing a WS of fact, or because there's been a…
… challenge we need an expert WS
AD no nothing like that
JB it says anyone within the PO can be an expert witness – were you ever told you could be an expert witness
AD no no one ever called me that.
JB takes AD to his 2nd WS par 53 – reads it out. tells him he is going to focus on "local work instruction documents"

JB you used LWID rather than F policy docs
AD yes
JB were they based on F policy docs
AD don't know
JB did you create LWID within PSS yourselves
AD on the HSD calls I can't remember if I did it off my own initiative or was asked to create them
JB so if there had been a tasking you would have been asked to create them by a manager
AD yes
JB did any manager approve the LWIDs?
AD don't know
JB why not
AD don't know
JB we have a suite of F docs which say how your work should be done and you say instead of using those, you used LWIDs
AD yes
JB so I'm trying to find out who signed them off to allow you to use them
AD I wrote many LWIDs within the key management arena
JB to what extent were they based on the requirement of F policies
AD no idea – they would have taken info from them
JB was any consideration given to it – we have to create a WS about say helpline calls – what does our policy say about that
AD no
JB on the one you say you drafted, does it say anything about the helpline calls to which you are referring should be summarised in the WS
AD no – it was just how to extract the calls
JB didn't tell you what to do with that data
AD no
JB didn't say you need to exhibit it
AD no
JB or you must analyse it
AD no
JB didn't say if you're unsure about an entry on an HSD log it's permissible or not permissible to speak to SSD about this and record it
AD no it didn't
JB so it didn't speak about any of the important things which should go into a WS
AD no
JB did it do anything to regularise how to deal with, say, HSD logs
AD no
JB because there are many ways of doing it [gives examples]
JB was there any written instruction on how you should or shouldn't record your extraction and how you went about it
AD no
JB oral instruction?
AD don't recall being told
JB advice or guidance?
AD no
JB you tell us in your WS you had limited tech knowlege of Horizon (H)
AD yes
JB no knowledge of bugs errors and defects (BEDs) in H
AD correct
JB and no knowledge of working in F support
AD yes
JB takes him to par 20 of AD's WS and reads it out

JB is that accurate – your role in the provision of WSs concerning calls to the helpdesk
AD yes
JB so this is a purely procedural/admin/mechanical role
AD yes
JB your function was a limited function
AD yes
JB so you did not have the tech expertise to know H was functioning at the relevant time?
AD in respect of the helpdesk calls yes I did
JB enough knowledge to say what was recorded on the calls could tell you whether H was working
AD yes I had that understand
JB so you were offering an opinion when you did this
AD yes
JB you were not making a statement of fact
AD yes
JB takes him to a spreadsheet disclosed by the PO but apparently prepared by F – a list of dates of requests for work received whether a statement was required for each case and who prepared it and whether statements was posted out or not 5/4/2004 to 22/3/2005

JB if we look at column F some things have been redacted – we think this is because a WS has been required

JB If we go to column N we can see who checks the WSs and if we do the drop down menu we see your name among others – is that the checking team?
AD yes
JB in one year you inputted into 98 requests

AD these are ARQ data checks – someone extracts it and someone else checks
JB what proportion of ARQ requests resulted in the production of a WS
AD no idea
JB always?
AD no no – quite infrequent
JB The column which says WS required has been redacted so we don't know. How often did you provide a WS
AD quite infrequently
JB over a year?
AD no idea – half a dozen
JB and you always did it in the same way – pulling up the template from the hard drive
AD yes
JB let's have a look at your second WS to look at your approach to WSs provided in support of PO prosecutions…
… and how happy you were about it.
JB [reads from the WS about Raj Baines not wanting to give evidence when it came to providing witness statements to court] but you were okay with it
AD yes
JB were you given any training by F or anyone about the way you extracted data…
… wrote WSs and presented it in court.
AD we had training on extracting ARQ data
JB the other bits
AD none at all
JB what thought did you give to the fact what you did may have had significant impacts on peoples' lives
AD I don't recall my thought process but "I took my role quite seriously" I was supplying data
JB in what way
AD I would do it to the best of my ability
JB was there anything aside from the extraction of the data you did in particular when providing the evidence
… or going to court.
AD i didn't do anything differently – i just performed the task to the best of my ability
JB takes him to a 2009 email re Porters Ave PO and the provision of a statement – run by Jerry Hosi [I know that name! saw him get his conviction quashed]

JB takes AD to Hosi's appeal judgment (he is one of the "others" in the appellants

JB goes to JH's case summary in that judgment

JB reads on over the page

More – ends with "we quash his conviction on all four counts".

JB takes him back to the email we were looking at earlier.
JB Lisa Allen was an investigator
AD can't remember
JB Phil Budd was a colleague
AD he worked on the account – didn't work that closely with him

JB shows this has been forwarded to AD with a note from Phil Budd

[Phil Budd is checking with AD that PO are not solely relying on his analysis]
JB why was PB not happy signing the statement the PO wanted him to sign
AD can't remember
JB did you discuss it with him – cajole him into signing a 'full working order'
AD would not have a convo on those lines no
JB you forward this to your manager Peter Sewell.
JB this is PS's reply to PB – what does it mean?
AD that after 42 days the messages store is no longer available – the rest I wasn't involved in…

JB PB was not happy saying in a WS that the counters were in full working order. He felt stress. This wasn't a complete refusal to provide a WS like Raj Baines, but first of all wanted to ensure his WS did not go beyond what he could not say
AD yes
JB and that…
… steps should be taken to do the work properly and check the system is working properly
AD [disagrees]
JB so he's saying that people should not rely solely on his analysis the PO should provide proper evidence
AD not sure
JB should this email have alerted you to the need to what you should or should not so when writing a WS yourself
AD dont' know
JB this is a systems engineer saying he's only going to speak to areas of which he has personal knowledge
AD yes
JB he's refusing to give a master opinion about the workings of the counters
AD yes
JB you gave WS's based on convos you had with others including in the SSC
AD yes
JB and you say this is what the SSC told you – but it didn't say that in your WS
AD yes
JB you ascribed it to your own personal knowledge
AD yes
JB did you realise that when you wrote WS which were in part based on what others told you which you could not speak to from your own personal knowledge that you were blurring lines?
AD no
JB did anyone tell you about this
AD no no one told me I had to state where I had gained my knowledge from
JB takes him back to p19 par 60 of AD's WS

JB reads from the email referred to above without it going up on the screen – says there was a lack of resource in the security team to extract and supply data using the correct legal terminology.
JB was Mr Peach right that there was a lack of resource…
… to extract the data and analyse it in court proceedings.
AD at that time no – I don't believe there was. In my role in supplying the WS and the call log data no I don't believe I did
JB Mr Peach suggested Gareth Jenkins could fill the gap…
… do you remember GJ deferred to you in the Misra trial re the reading of the call logs.
AD no
JB in your WS you say you passed on analysis from SSC about what entries in HSD call logs meant and whether that would have had an effect on the operation of the H system. And you…
… presented that as your own analysis.
AD yes
JB was that appropriate given their reluctance to provide that function themselves
AD no
JB you are calling them up, getting their analysis and presenting it as your own even tho they don't want to do it
AD once I'd spoke to people I had that understanding so it was within my knowledge
JB so because someone tells you something you can repurpose it as your own
AD no I understood it and so I then knew it
JB did it ever occur to you to wonder why you were speaking to what the SSC
… was saying and yet the SSC don't want to say it themselves
AD no
JB did you think at all why SSC did not want to give evidence
AD I know Mik Peach was protective of his team
JB did anyone decide it was fine for you to give SSC evidence in court
AD well…?
JB did anyone sign it off?
AD they were aware I was doing it and accepted I was able to do that – I would have had discos
JB did anyone give explicit approval to it
AD I would have taken approval as their awareness – if they thought i shouldn't be doing it…
… they should have said.
JB was there a relationship with Mik P being protective of his team and you taking a greater role
AD no recollection. Don't believe so.
[we take a break]
[we're back]
JB takes AD to his WS
JB can you explain what you mean by due diligence – your approach – what prompted you to make a call to SSC after reading a call log
AD I would have carried out an investigation and looked through each of the calls

JB what did your investigation consist of
AD print out and read them and if there was an area I didn't quite understand as to how it was resolved I would consult
JB who did you consult and how did you identify them
AD knowledge of people
JB did you go back to the person named in the call log?
AD can't remember – may have done at times – not always no
JB would you phone them?
AD no i'd often go and see them on the sixth floor – as I had a lot of dealings with them about other matters
JB you can't remember…
… how you id'd someone to speak to – was it who was on duty at that moment
AD most likely
JB did you make a record of that convo
AD no – I might have made a note of what I had to do, but not of the convo
JB were you made aware it might be a requirement
AD no
JB if this was going before a crim court
AD no
JB and you did not know what you were told was right or wrong
AD I don't know
JB [repeats q]
AD these are the people who dealt with these calls I'd have to rely on their own knowledge
JB so you couldn't know if what they were saying was right or wrong
AD I didn't know the answer prior to the investigation
JB prior to speaking to them
AD yes
JB so you didn't know what they were telling you was true or false
AD I suppose so yes
JB why did you want to speak to them
AD because they had a far greater tech knowledge than i did.
JB did you know whether you had to explain in your WS…
.. was in fact not based on your own knowledge but what someone told you
AD I didn't know I had to state that and as I said before and I though that was part of my own knowledge – so I knew about it
JB who gave you advice about your interactions with the SSC and how to put it in a WS
AD relied on management. they were aware of what I was doing
JB name names pls
AD any of my security managers at the time…
… Brian Pinder, Pete Sewell, Donna Munro…
JB did you have access to legal advice within F
AD not sure – wasn't made aware I did
JB were you aware there were lawyers within F
AD I think so
JB did you ever seek advice from lawyers within F over these matters
AD no
JB did your managers? on the specific issue of putting other people's knowledge in your WS when they themselves were refusing to go to court
AD don't think they did
JB takes AD to par 115 of his WS

JB you describe here how you satisfied yourself that call data had no impact on integrity of H data – who told you you had to satisfy yourself about this
AD no one
JB did you see it as your role to give assurance – ie no impact on integrity of H data
AD I would have to because of the wording of the WS
JB did you see it as your role to provide assurance that what you read in the call logs had no impact on H data
AD yes it was my role
JB did you provide a WS in all your years where you saw a call log did challenge H data
AD no
JB did you ever say a call ever possibly challenge integrity of H data
AD no
JB so nothing you ever read over decades you ever saw anything which challenged H data
AD no I didn't
JB goes to par 196 of AD's WS

JB so whenever you saw in an HSD record that a call had been referred to NBSC you thought it was routine and not a tech error
AD corr
JB so that assumes the HSD were always right to refer to NBSC
AD yes
JB and assumes that if the SPM thought it was a tech error then they were wrong
AD if a call was referred to NBSC I would have thought it was a user error or business issue
JB so you assumed HSD had got it right and the SPM was wrong
AD no because if it was a tech issue
… it would get referred back to HSD
JB [pushes the point]
AD [accepts]
JB did you have access to what happened when a call was referred to NBSC
AD no
JB so you didn't know what happened when a call went to NBSC
AD no
JB so if they said turn it on and off again, you wouldn't know that
AD no
JB you wouldn't know if they were told they were liable
AD no
JB you wouldn't know if told they had to pay up burying the issue
AD no
JB you put these all down as routine calls
AD it was a routine
JB isn't what you were conveying was not about the frequency but that these calls do not involve a system issue
AD ?
JB you weren't talking about the frequency of the calls being routine
… you were saying there's no issue with H
AD no
JB might that not suggest there's a big system issue if these problems have become routine
AD no because of the types of calls
JB wants to go summarising or exhibiting call logs – did you sometimes exhibit and sometimes summarise
AD sometimes summarise
JB why
AD dependent on what the PO wanted
JB so they specified that
AD yes
JB do you know why they did this
AD no
JB did it occur to you that sometimes you were handing over the raw product and sometimes summarising it
AD no I knew full well the raw data was available if requested. If they requested data it was supplied.
JB takes him to the Castleton case where the full call logs were exhibited…



JB goes back to Jerry Hosi's case – wants AD to remember the phrase highlighted in yellow

JB takes AD to his WS for the JH case (notes that HSH is the same as HSD – the F code for the H helpline)

JB so you're exhibiting a CD of all the calls and then moving down you use the "routine" nature line

JB and scrolling down you provide a summary of the calls

JB call 2 – is that routine because it was passed to NBSC – must have been a business issue
AD yes

JB so in Castleton case there is a printout of all the call records, in JH case we get a CD and a summary
AD yes
JB let's go to the Misra case…
… this is what you say about it in your WS. You gave more and more details about the HSD calls on request.
AD yes

JB what determined which approach you took?
AD it all would have depended on convos with the PO investigator or lawyer. Always the starting point – a high level overview of the calls and progressed from there. If the wanted all the calls at teh starting point that's what they'd..
… get.
JB would the PO person ever explain what prompted them to explain why they wanted more
AD no
JB whether it was a query in your info, whether the defendant was querying it or the court
AD could have been any of the above
JB asks how he could come up with his conclusion in the JH case

JB to what extent was your opinion here formed by consultation with others
AD don't know
JB takes him to two critical events noted in one of the JH case calls to HSD

JB where did you get this info from
AD can't remember specifically
JB you would have got the info from somewhere else – that was not your own personal knowledge
AD I agree
JB so this is an opinion based on someone else's opinion
AD er…
JB you say the reboot repaired the problem
AD yes, trying to explain what took place in that call
[JB moves on]
We got to an email AD sent to Dave Posnett in the PO security team 22 June 2009 re the Misra case

JB takes him to and reads out the reply

JB so your statement mentioned 107 calls, you were picked up on this… and we see Jon Longman's reply asking you for a breakdown

JB and your response saying 107 wasn't much.
JB did you think it was routine for a branch to have to call the helpline around once a week
AD yes in my opinion it didn't seem that much

JB was the frequency of the calls a proxy for whether the substance of the calls was routine
AD no I don't believe I did
JB asks again
AD I don't know – I was just responding re 107 calls and did the maths and gave my opinion
JB okay – you go on to say to get the summaries…
… will be one or two days of work…
JB scrolling up… this is JL's response… just to mention the frequency for now…
JB would the substance of the calls make a difference as to whether the number was different

AD I was just giving an opinion on the frequency. It didn't seem a lot
JB and you did as JL requested – you sent a WS saying there were a 107 calls and that was not a high number
AD no that was an add on to my original statement
JB let's see what happened after you signed off the statement – costs disco which you weren't part of.
JB was what you put in a WS affected by the cost of it?

AD I never knew that it was. I didn't know there was charging or a cost estimate on the work I carried out
JB so if there was an effect – that info never found its way to you
JB so you just did what you were asked to do and didn't know the extent to which financial considerations affected the choice which had to be made
AD correct
[we move to another email chain still on the Misra case re the F helpline calls.]

JB so you appear to be querying in this chain whether you should exhibit the CD
AD is not sure so we scroll down further to the below questions

then JB takes him back to his question
AD having seen the questions I think is a disco re supplying the call data – does he want them printed out or on a CD – it's just about presentation
JB it's not whether or not the raw data should be provided
AD no
JB do you know why you would not provide the raw data
AD depends on what the PO wanted
[JB moves on]
[An email chain about supplying a disc of data in the Misra case]

Then we go to a WS provided by AD with a CD of underlying data exhibited.
JB what would be on that CD
AD the call logs in their entirety.
SWW did you give oral evidence in Jerry Hosi's case?
AD dont' believe I did, no.
[we have another break]

[so much for my plans of being able to give you verbatim quotes. I think you can have verbatim quotes in real-ish time OR the documents as they appear and a summary of what's being said. On balance I think the latter is better]
[we are back]
JB takes AD to his 2009 WS in the Misra case…

JB goes to the bottom of the page and reads it out

JB so you provided a short WS which just gave the number of calls made by the Misras and an opinion.
AD yes
JB was that a standard approach – put a number, an opinion and then wait to see what happened
AD there was no standard approach
AD we did what the PO wanted
JB in JH's case you did a summary of the calls – what determined what the entry-level point was – ie the first statement you provided
AD the PO
JB any idea what influenced them when they made requests?
AD no
JB okay let's go back to the boilerplate stuff in the WS to see what they were for or what you intended them to mean….
JB takes him to a 2002 email chain

JB Graham Hooper was your manager
AD yes
JB we know who Graham Ward is – okay this is an email to Hooper thanking him – it is forwarded to Martin Riddell and you are cc'd

… and pats on the back all round… as the email is forwarded again… AD seems to find the "caring sharing manager" line funny
JB were you involved in supplying data back then
AD don't know. I did start in 2002 – can't say

JB in 2002 was there a standard form WS in the security
AD believe so [he said there wasn't at the High Court and this is how he got into trouble]
JB was there always a standard form WS
AD [quickly] yes
JB takes him to a doc similar to the one that began today's session, except this is three years earlier

Graham Ward from the PO is listed as a reviewer who returned comments on this policy doc

There is a 32 page appendix of a template WS which includes lettered pars eg:

JB goes back to the main doc and the par that refers to it

JB did you know this policy existed. did you see it
AD don't believe so
JB takes him to par Q in the template – were you required to say this in each and every case
AD don't know I was required to
JB its in all your WS
AD so it was in the template we'd be told to use

JB how do you know it was true or false?
AD I believed it was working as it should
JB how did you know that
AD in respect of ARQs I knew checks were being made every time we extracted data and with the HSD calls and believe it is operating as it should and as expected
JB what's the "it" in that sentence
AD the counters and…
JB stop there – you were saying the counters were working fine
AD yes
JB and then you said and… what else?
AD trying to say all was working well so not to affect the integrity of the data
JB so this is an opinion or view on H itself
AD yes
JB how would you know it was true or false
AD based on the investigation I carried out
JB how could you say there was no reason to believe it was inaccurate due to improper use of the computer
AD I made that assumption, my opinion on every call I looked at. I was asked for an opinion and that was my opinion
[JB goes to AD's inquiry WS]
par 96

into par 97

JB reads out par 98

JB you are saying here you thought improper use of software was about the audit extraction software
AD er… yes
JB in par 100 you say you did not think you were verifying the system as a whole

JB so you're saying when you put that par Q in your WS you had a positive understanding of what it meant and what it didn't mean
AD yes
JB and that it was only limited to the reliability or use of the audit extraction software and not H as a whole
AD yes
JB was that your contemporaneous belief in all the years you were signing statements in prosecutions
AD yes
[JB goes to a new doc – transcript of his evidence to the High Court 28 March 2019]

JB takes him forward to p41 where he is being xe'd by Mr Miletic

it continues…
JB so you're being asked the same q in the High Court as I was asking you earlier about the same par Q
JB now there you say you're not sure what you meant. How was it in 2019 you were saying you're not sure by par Q, but now you're telling us it only meant the…

… audit extraction software and not H in its entirety
AD not sure what I was thinking
JB it goes on… and you do say it's about the workstations, but you weren't sure – how are you so sure now
AD not sure. i was put on the spot. I can't say what I was thinking at the time.

[we go to Jo Hamilton's case Jan 2007]

JB here a fault appears to be identified – and your reply to ignore the WS you sent.

JB Let's go to the one you signed on 14 Jan. Here is a summary of that. This is the WS and you don't provide clarification as requested
AD no

JB on its face this call doesn't record a resolution, just that the call was closed
AD no it was to get the SPM to do a manual reboot
JB and it doesn't record if that was successful
AD not on that call no
JB on any other call
AD in the next call it didn't work and…
… an engineer is called.
JB so a potential fault was identified and you were asked about it and you didn't respond
AD not in the email no
JB or in your WS
AD I did an investigation
JB how
AD i looked at everything avail
JB such as
AD KELs
JB you would have looked at KELs would you
AD yes
JB there are two listed there – would you look both up
AD yes

JB and the KELs did not assist in saying whether there was or wasn't a fault in Josephine Hamilton's branch
AD yes and if I needed assistance on the KELs I'd go to SSC and ask, as they had created them
JB takes him to the first KEL

JB fault on disk drive… then there's some code. What does that code mean
AD no not now
JB would you understand it at the time
AD yes, well, no, I'd speak to the SSC

JB they were the experts not you
AD yes
JB the experts that didnt' want to give evidence…
JB goes to solution helpdesk section… "test… follow appropriate KELs… more serious fault… motherboard… send an engineer" you see it continues…
JB takes him to the second KEL

JB reads the problem section

JB reads from some of the Solution section. It seems to involve "squirrels"

JB reading as you said you did, how did this not disclose anything other than the system not operating properly
AD I would have read this – these were known errors and so these would have been seen before
JB is that a good thing
AD there would be a way of dealing with it
JB how were you able to say this was H operating without problems
AD no effect on the counters. it was still working as expected – there may have been faults at the counter but that is still within the boundaries of faults at the H system – it wouldn't have affected the…
…integrity of the data between the branch and H
JB did you look at the data to see whether there were any integrity issues?
AD at the data?
JB yes.
AD no.
JB thank you.
[we break for lunch]
[we're back and we're going to look again at the prosecution of Jerry Hosi]
JB takes AD to his WS in the JH case

more…
JB reads the "routine nature" par

JB takes him to the "boilerplate" par

JB you see there at the "boilerplate" par Q in the policy docs we looked at this morning – the "improper use of the computer" par is not present in this WS. I think I put this morning that par Q is in all of your WSs… I think it's in all WSs to do with ARQ data, but NOT…
in WSs to do with call logs. Why is that?
AD don't know
JB restates the question
AD I don't know why the two were different – the statements weren't fixed cos I could add things or PO could ask for things to be removed or put in so most of the time it would have been a disco
AD I can't recall what the process was what the discos were or why it was left out.
JB okay. JB quotes "I make this Witness Statement from facts within my own knowledge unless otherwise stated."
JB asks what this means
AD that's within my own knowledge – I believe I knew those facts the knowledge [word soup]
JB can you not see to make a statement including that line there could never be a case where you would state "unless othewise stated"
AD ???
JB to make a statement it has to be within your own knowledge or you couldn't make the statement
AD correct
JB so what's the purpose of the line
AD I don't know its part of the standard WS we wer told to use
JB did you not understand it to mean…
… that if you don't say something, it's your own knowledge and if you do say something it's stated.
JB did you know this at the time or did you just put it in
AD [quickly] no I had an undertstanding it was in my knowledge base
JB if that's the case when could you "otherwise…
… state"
AD I don't know
JB on your explanation, that sentence makes no sense – if everything you state is within your own knowledge, you could never state otherwise
AD if you read it that way, these were statements which were written and agreed to be used.
JB quotes this par

JB if you had no expertise in H – what qualifies you to make this statement
AD it was my opinion at the time based on the knowledge I had
JB takes him to a version of the statement made two days later – exactly the same save the word "effect" has been changed to "affect"
[weird]

JB takes him to a call summary in that WS

Conclusion over the page

JB you say this is the system working as it should. How are you able to say that
AD because it was referred to NBSC – it was resolved to the satisfaction of all parties
JB where did you get that from
AD I assumed it had to be resolved because it never came back
JB is that how you informed your opinion in a WS to the criminal courts – assumption?
AD that the calls had been resolved, yes
JB but you didn't know one way or the other, did you?
AD the NBSC was a helpdesk to resolve issues, yes
JB but you didn't know what happened, did you
AD [agrees]
JB so why tell the court that a referral to the NBSC was routine and would not have had an effect on a counter
AD if it was passed to the NBSC it was a business issue
JB so that assumes the HSH person has got it right
AD correct
JB even if the SPM was saying…
… it was a system issue. You took the view that if it was passed to the NBSC that made it a business issue
AD yes because if it was an H issue it would have got referred back
JB so the second assumption is that if it was not referred back it was a business issue
JB moves to call summary 8

and then skims through lots of error calls until alighting on error 33
JB how did the reboot confirm the stability of the system?
AD it confirmed the counters were back working again

JB did the calls record how long the call handler waiting to see if any problems continued
AD don't know
JB did the calls record if the event caused problems balancing
AD no it doesn't state that
JB so you don;t know one way or another
AD I don;t know how long they looked…
… at events.
JB so if the SPM didn't raise it again – you assume there was no problem
AD yes the fault had been fixed at the time so yes I do
JB did you know the NBSC advised settling discrepancies
AD no
JB when investigating…
… problems like this did you investigate the KELS
AD yes
JB did you ever set out what you found in the KELS
AD no
JB if you found something of relevance would you include it in your WS
AD I don't know
JB did you have the tech knowledge to know what had happened
AD no but at the time I believed I understood
JB did you ask anyone else at F if you didn't understand what was in these call logs
AD yes people in SSC
JB the Inquiry has heard about Callendar Sq and Riposte Lock…
… errors when rebooting a system in the face of a problem actually caused more problems
AD no
JB let's look at the J Simpkins KEL which you said earlier today you would have gone and had a look at…

JB goes to the solution

JB there's nothing in your WS or summary of the call logs that rebooting could cause an imbalance
AD no
JB or that this had been happening for years
AD this is part of the routine handling of calls and an error which has a resolution to it, so it's fine
JB which of the multiple..
… resolutions applies in this case?
AD it was out of hours, I think
JB you don't seem to have seen what the solution which should have been applied in this case
AD I don't know how I balanced this up… I believe this one wasn't during working hours
JB yes – that's the first part of the solution – I'm looking at the later parts of the solution
AD yes I can't see how I got to my solution
JB did you carry out an investigation, come to a solution and balance it up, or did you cut and paste a summary from the call logs
AD no that's not my way of working
JB you did a proper investigation of every call
AD yes
JB that's a lot of work
AD it is
JB hours and hours
AD it could be, yes
JB takes him to a 3 June 2008 email which we saw from a PO investigator earlier asking for a full statement including outcome of faults reported, and Dunks' response.

JB takes him to the WS delivered an hour later which resulted in the addition of a line – that it didn't affect the working of the counters and discrepancies

JB so you have added in an hour that all 33 calls did not affect counter discrepancies – a material addition
AD yes
JB let's go back to the email
JB you refer to this being discussed and that's why you were able to turn it round so quickly
AD I'd like to think so yes

JB and here, you turn this request around in just over an hour because all you're doing is just turning a summary into a full complement of logs
AD yes

JB takes him to an email exchange on the Misra case – starts with Anne Chambers to Gareth Jenkins forwarded to AD via Penny Thomas.

JB goes to the beginning of the chain

and more…

… to the end of the email

JB reads up the chain

and back where we started "you might like to check…"
JB did you do so?
AD I'd like to think so
JB did you do anything
AD can't remember
JB you said you would have satisfied yourself that the data was okay

AD I did
JB so what did you do
AD I can't remember
JB what could you have done – did you understand what AC was suggesting?
AD yes
JB you don't record your investigations in your WS
AD after I'd looked at these if my opinions hadn't changed I wouldnt need to add anything
JB is that how you consistently operated – that if you did an investigation and it didn't change your opinion you didn't need to make a record of that investigation
AD no one told me to
JB takes him to a call log in the Misra case in 2006 – she's £6000 down, but she's referred to NBSC within two minutes – this is, in your world, not an IT fault.
AD because she's being referred to NBSC

JB we move on to another call – Misra is still £6000 down, was cut off during call to NBSC –

JB PM calls up with H showing different values for the certain products

JB is taking AD through lots of Misra call logs – skimming through them…
JB so an SPM repeatedly calling the helpdesk and being referred to NBSC and on this basis this is the system operating as intended. This is the SPM not the system
AD if it's passed to NBSC, yes
JB so when you say all the calls were routine you were relying on the accuracy and truth of what was written here?
AD yes and spoken to people
JB who
AD possibly Anne herself

JB how was this call of a routine nature
AD postmasters had a discrepancy – they were routine in nature
JB was everything you saw in F over the decades you worked there routine
AD I don't know
JB what was the outcome of this call
AD the NBSC investigated – I believed they…
… resolved the issue.
JB how did you believe that
AD it didn't come back to us
JB what if NBSC told the SPM that they'd done all the investigation possible and it was their job to pay up
AD I don't know anything about that
JB that's all my q's thanks mr dunks, you've been…
… very helpful.
JB Sir there are qs from core participants. can we have a 10 minute break so they can sort themselves out
SWW yes
[10 min break]
[we're back. Flora Page asking qs she notes that she reps Lee Castleton and Seema Misra]
FP you were loyal to F
AD ?
FP you'd been there man and boy
AD yes 30 years
FP and you'd do anything to protect F
AD no
FP takes him to an email we've seen before between AD and his boss Peter Sewell. She reads it out
FP you were going to be loyal to F no matter what
AD it doesn't say that no – it's about giving me confidence
FM nasty chap, out to rubbish the F name
AD no I had to be strong…

FP let's look at your reply
FP what did that mean, Mr Dunks
AD I got on well with Pete. I was saying thank you – I believe in your support
FP this was obviously sarcastic – did you really have to wipe away a small tear?
AD no
FP it was sarcasm
AD possibly

AD no bad intention – the relationship we had at the time
FP you're joking about a man whose future was on the line
AD don't see it like that – weren't joking about what we were doing
FP banter, isn't it
AD it could have been
FP banter
AD yes to put me at ease
FP this was copied to Penny Thomas and Lowther – team email
AD yes
FP deeply partisan team out to stop the nasty SPMs out to rubbish the F name
AD no it was to put me at ease to tell me they had my support and my backing
FP goes back to an email about Seema Misra shown earlier by Jason Beer
FP the way this is presented suggests that Penny Thomas printed off this email
AD not sure

FP okay it looks like PT has printed off the email alongside your witness statement suggesting all the calls in the misra case were of a routine nature

FP so your WS says everything is routine, but the email chain from Anne Chambers says everything needs further investigation
AD yes
FP would you accept this email chain put a burden on you to check your WS was correct and not misleading
AD yes
FP so when you get this email from AC you should have checked
AD I would have done the work, yes
FP so you did the work set out by AC
AD I'd like to think I did
FP [lists everything AC says needs to happen]
FP did you do that
AD like to think so
FP at this point there was no ARQ data so how did you do the investigation
AD this is referring to the help desk
FP how did you know the counters were being used without the ARQ data
AD I don't know what I did, but I'd like to think that I did
FP but you didn't have the info you needed to do the investigation, yet you produced a WS saying it was all routine
AD because of what I did to investigate if I believed I didn't need any info I didn't need to change…
… my WS.
FP reads to the email

FP you did not have the data to do the investigation and yet you said it was routine
AD I can't remember what I did , but I would have been satisfied
FP at the very least you needed to qualify the statement to say what you knew
AD to say nothing had changed…
FP but you did nothing
AD if it was still true, no update needed
FP how could it still be true if there were investigations needed and those investigations could not be carried out
AD if I thought nothing needed changing I wouldn't change it
FP we know you made WSs without stating the info you'd got
… from the SSC. And we know Mik Peach from the SSC had refused to make WSs from his team because he was protective of them, and you told us that was not related
AD yes
FP we can see that relationship in action.. [takes him to the AC comment]

FP you were happy to keep her volunteering
AD well…
FP you were covering for her as she didn't want to stand up in court
AD not covering for her – I was doing what I was asked to do
FP you didn't tell Mik Peach that AC should give evidence
AD no
FP you were covering for SSC because they didn't want to give evidence
AD no
FP remember in the High Court you told the judge there was no F party line and then you admitted there was when you were shown the Gareth Jenkins WS –
AD I misinterpreted what he meant by party line
FP yes and you're now clinging to this – the idea that you were told to put wording into your WS
AD that's what I meant at the time
FP so your process driven misleading statements were your own work
AD no my understanding of party line was that we are all told to hold a line…
… and not waver. When I understood it was about templates I agreed that was what we used
FP you haven't been prepared to revealed who drafted those templates or who was in charge of them
AD they were used by us
FP who drafted them
AD someone within F
FD someone…
FP the par re "improper use of the computer" line – you've used that wording yourself many times, and you've used it replacing the words "the computer" and "the system"
AD okay
FP what was the difference?
AD don't know. still conveying the same opinion
FP what was that opinion
AD what it said
FP who instigated that change
AD I don't know
SWW was it you Mr Dunks – did you deliberately change the word "computer" for "system" or was there a template
AD there wasn't a template
SWW so was it you
AD it must have been after discussion with the PO and what they wanted. The WS evolved over the years. I can't remember how the process changed or who instigated the changes
SWW so you have no idea who instigated the change
AD no they mean the same thing
SWW there's your answer Ms Page – mean the same thing
FP well Gareth Jenkins thought "the computer" meant the computer he was typing his statement on
AD don't know how he came to that conclusion
FP how did he come to have the template wording GJ used
AD not sure I saw any of GJs WSs – I',m assuming he used the same templates we used
FP was this dealt with at a level above you? Was someone in charge of the template and how it was used
AD [long pause] erm….
… I believe so… yes.
FP who
AD [another very long pause]
FP is your loyalty getting in the way here mr dunks
AD my loyalty…?
FP is that why you're being so cagey
AD I don't know who wrote the templates…
FP and you don't know who changed them
AD that would have come from discussions with the PO
FD was it your loyalty that led you not to reveal the existence of the KELs in your statements?
AD know we knew they were there
FP did anyone ever tell you not to reveal what KEL stood for
AD no never
[FP finishes. Sam Stein KC asks next qs]
SS want to ask re Horizon Online – when was HOL updated to a new operating system from Windows NT4 – if it was
AD I can't remember
AD maybe when HNGX was rolled out
SS if you are right about it being when HNGX happened – when would that be
AD no idea
SS we know the PO is hoping to move on from H by April 2025 – we are told the new system is going to be called NBIT – how is that going?
AD you're asking the wrong person I have no idea
SS really?
AD no I've seen nothing. all I know is that the dates for the end of the contract have moved from the original date and it's been pushed back
SWW is that it Mr Beer
JB it is sir yes
[SWW thanks Dunks…
… and ends the session.
JB confirms we'll be back at 1005 tomorrow to deal with the evidence from Ken McCall – a former PO NED, NOT supplied by the government.]
Okay that's me – lots do to on Dunks – I'll try to get something coherent up soon.
Thanks for reading.
And here's your write up…
www.postofficescandal.uk/post/andy-dunks-big-problem/


