-
Post Office legal strategy: “force the claimants to burn money”
Read More…: Post Office legal strategy: “force the claimants to burn money”The second day of Andy Parsons’ evidence (see here for a piece on the first) was short with only a few new documents to consider. One was another piece of corroboration that the Post Office strategy during Bates v Post Office – the seminal legal battle which blew the lid off the scandal – was to run the claimants out of road. Today we saw a document in which Andy Parsons, a Womble Bond Dickinson lawyer tasked with co-ordinated the Post Office’s defence of Bates v Post Office told his colleagues on 1 Nov 2018 (the eve of the first…
-
Post Office lawyer: Postmasters are liars
Read More…: Post Office lawyer: Postmasters are liarsA civil litigation lawyer instructed by the Post Office branded campaigning former Subpostmasters Jo Hamilton, Noel Thomas and Seema Misra “liars and criminals” whilst discussing PR strategy with his clients. Andy Parsons from Bond Dickinson was advising the Post Office on their media response to a 2015 episode of Panorama which featured all three Subpostmasters. In an internal email to the Post Office legal team, revealed today at the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry, Parsons noted that trying to argue the technical legal points around the prosecution of Jo Hamilton would not be “worthwhile” as the “man in street” would…
-
Lord Grabiner: Never Mind “That Bollox”
Read More…: Lord Grabiner: Never Mind “That Bollox”Lord Grabiner strode into the Inquiry hearing room wielding a walking cane. As he didn’t appear to be using it to support himself it rather gave the impression it might be utilised to punish impertinence. Jason Beer KC, who asked questions on behalf of the inquiry, appeared unruffled. Grabiner was called to explore his apparent firm belief that there was something so wrong with Mr Justice Fraser’s Common Issues trial judgment that Fraser should be removed as managing judge of the Bates v Post Office group litigation. Grabiner’s ace in the hole was a six page document written by Lord…
-
De Garr Robinson’s Jenkins problem
Read More…: De Garr Robinson’s Jenkins problemPoor old Tony Robinson, just trying to make an honest crust defending his client, whilst being misled by his instructing solicitors (Womble Bond Dickinson), his client’s supplier (Fujitsu) or possibly even his client – the Post Office! As leading counsel for the Post Office in the Horizon Issues trial during Bates v Post Office, de Garr Robinson regularly seemed to be on the receiving end of duff information, which he took at face value and dutifully represented to to the High Court as fact. This, as he described in his witness statement, was sub-optimal. Recalling the first such occasion, he…
-
Post Office refuses to say how much Grabiner and Neuberger cost
Read More…: Post Office refuses to say how much Grabiner and Neuberger costOn 4 October 2023, I asked the Post Office to disclose the fee notes for Lords Grabiner and Neuberger under the Freedom of Information Act. I thought it would be interesting to know just how much public cash the Post Office used to spend on their advice, which informed the Post Office’s decision to demand Mr Justice Fraser recuse himself as managing judge of the Bates v Post Office litigation . On 20 Dec 2023, the Post Office refused to hand over the fee notes. On 28 Dec 2023 I asked the Post Office to review their decision (giving various…
-
More dispatches from the Post Office bunker: the PR guy goes Tonto
Read More…: More dispatches from the Post Office bunker: the PR guy goes TontoOn 1 Dec 2014 I was in Cornwall, where Tim Robinson, Jane Goddard, Joe Cooper and I had been filming with former Subpostmaster Sue Knight. After 32 years service Sue had been sacked and prosecuted by the Post Office for false accounting. Although the prosecution had been dropped, Sue’s life was falling apart. She had lost her job and reputation and was in the process of losing her home. Her mental health was in tatters. Our interview with Sue was due to go out in January as part of two films the Inside Out South team were making for the…
-
The taxi for Paula Vennells which never quite came
Read More…: The taxi for Paula Vennells which never quite cameA powerpoint slide deck was the most newsworthy element to leap out of former Post Office chair Alice Perkins’ second day of evidence at the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry today. Thanks to an anonymous nine-page presentation, we know that in February 2014 the government was tempted to sack Post Office CEO Paula Vennells because people were saying she wasn’t very good at her job. To give some context, by 2014, Paula Vennells was coming up to two years in post. The Post Office’s complaint and mediation scheme for Subpostmasters was underway. Independent investigators Second Sight were digging into the…
-
Perkins in Wonderland: Day 1
Read More…: Perkins in Wonderland: Day 1The Post Office scandal did not happen, or get covered up because of a single Machiavellian baddie. It happened because a bunch of serially incompetent people spent oodles of other people’s cash groping their way around a crisis without the competence or moral backbone to do the right thing. Alice Perkins, Chair of the Post Office between 2011 and 2015, has all the hallmarks of a capable, clever person. And it’s true that capable, clever people sometimes makes serious mistakes, or lots of regular stupid mistakes, whilst surrounded by people making similar stupid mistakes. Maybe. But, come on. The short…
-
Perkins Preview: what secrets will Lady Humphrey reveal?
Read More…: Perkins Preview: what secrets will Lady Humphrey reveal?Alice Perkins was Chairman of the Post Office for four years between 2011 and 2015. She got the job after a career spent in the civil service. One of the people who ostensibly worked for her during that period told me Perkins was “patronising… wooden and inarticulate”, complaining she “couldn’t connect with people at all… we used to see her about twice a year and she would give speeches that made you numb with boredom.” This is exactly what you might expect from a career civil servant. It might serve to lower your expectations for the next two days of…
-
Grey Day gives little away
Read More…: Grey Day gives little awayChris Day, former Post Office Chief Financial Office had all the hallmarks of a low-wattage witness. He met that expectation square on. I think I was the only journalist present today. More fool me. Taken at snail’s pace through multiple documents we’ve seen before, Day was unable to see the real risks in the Horizon system from the moment he joined in August 2011, to when he left in December 2014. One of the first things to hit his desk was the Ismay report. Day was Rod Ismay’s boss. We have met Mr Ismay before. Today Catriona Hodge, asking questions…