Secret email about the Post Office Scandal. Shh!

No full Capture appeal hearings likely before 2027

Plus: New HSS fixed fee appeal scheme

bfc19797a43256b60f761d24d6054a0b8e2244d1.jpeg
Once more…

Hello from the bowels of the Royal Courts of Justice where I am sitting a freezing cold press room. My fingers have gone numb. Nonetheless, it’s always fun to work here and it was worthwhile going to the RCJ today for a few reasons.

Firstly it was nice to make direct contact with Steve Marston, the Subpostmaster who has effectively been leading the way with the Capture appeals process. He seems like a lovely fellow.

It was also very useful to re-make contact with the barristers and solicitors from both sides today. Simon Baker KC was a junior representing the Post Office during the 2021 appeals hearing and Tim Moloney KC was today acting for Hudgell’s, as he was five years ago.

Both were helpful in that they seemed to be doing their best to secure some documents requested by journalists which will hopefully shed some more light on the way the appeals and the response to the appeals are being positioned. Though the fact none of us actually got any documents out of the court today was not a great sign.

Edge Case

There was one extraordinary and highly unexpected moment right at the start of proceedings this afternoon, when a smartly-dressed litigant-in-person sought to persuade the three judges who will be hearing the Capture appeals (and they are not just Capture appeals, but more on that in a moment) that they should also hear his appeal despite being prosecuted on the back of two pieces of paper in the early 1980s.

Simon Edgecombe (who I met and spoke to both before and after the hearing) was prosecuted for theft by the Post Office in 1983. The way he tells it, he was required to source a van for a Postmaster in Kent.

He turned up with the van, but the Postmaster was not there, so he gave a copy of his invoice to a Ms [redacted] who was working behind the Post Office counter. She gave him £750 in cash from the counter and recorded the transaction on some blotting paper sitting on top of the counter.

That day the branch was subject to a sudden audit. The auditors found around £1000 missing. Ms [redacted] was asked where it was and she told the auditors she’d given some of it to Mr Edgecombe.

The investigators were alerted. They took the blotting paper and the invoice and went round to Mr Edgecombe’s house and asked if he had been given money from the Post Office counter by Ms [redacted]. He said he had. They asked to see his copy of the invoice. He gave it to them (and never saw it again).

Next thing he knew he and Ms [redacted] were being charged with theft “from an employer”, despite Edgecombe not being employed by the Post Office. He pleaded not guilty but was found guilty by majority verdict (as was Ms [redacted]) at Maidstone Crown Court. Edgecombe was sentenced to 20 months in prison.

If that is what happened, it’s obviously mad. Unfortunately, Mr Edgecombe had lots of reasons why he didn’t appeal at the time, and now simply has nothing to back up his version of the story. No documentary evidence of the case exists (according to the Post Office).

Today Edgecombe reached the end of the road. The panel of judges, led by Lord Justice Edis, had considered Mr Edgecombe’s paper submissions and come to a decision. Edis read out the judgment explaining how Mr Edgecombe’s appeal had failed.

When Edis had finished, he told Edgecombe it was all over. Edgecombe, who had sat politely at the front of court listening to his hopes being slowly and methodically dismantled by the ruling, asked if he could have permission to say one thing.

Edis said he could, but asked if he could be mindful of the time as there were the other cases to be getting on with.

Addressing the panel of judges directly, Edgecome said: “Please do not trust what Post Office tell you. I’ll leave that one with you.”

Slowly Grinding

Attention then turned to the directions hearing for the three cases referred to the Court of Appeal by the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC).

Two are Capture cases. One is known as an APT case, which stands for Automatic Payment Terminal, a bit of kit used by the Post Office at the turn of this century which consisted of an electronic terminal connected to a telephone line used to carry out rent, rates and utility bill transactions.

Gareth Snow, who used to run the Corwen Post Office branch in Denbighshire, was audited in November 2000. The auditors say they found a deficit of £57,000 and charged Mr Snow with false accounting, which he admitted on the basis that “errors caused by the APT had resulted in merely accounting shortfalls”.

The CCRC think he’s got a case. There’s more on the CCRC website.

The other two appellants are Capture appellants. Steve Marston, as mentioned above, and Patricia Owen, who sadly died in 2003. She was being represented in court today by her widower, Mr Owen.

At the start of proceedings, Tim Moloney told the judges that Mr Owen was not in very good health, and whilst he was aware of the time and resource pressures on the Court of Appeal, he would be very grateful if they could find a way to hold the full Capture/APT hearing this year.

Mr Moloney then set out the agreed schedule between the Post Office and the appellants for getting the case court ready, which both parties agreed would be by 2 October.

Lord Justice Edis said the court needed a full week to do the case justice: Monday to do their reading, Tuesday to Thursday to hear the arguments and then Friday to “reflect” and begin preparing their judgment.

He felt it was important that the existing “constitution” of the court stick together, but because the other two justices (Lord Picken and Lady Farby, both of whom sat alongside Lord Holroyde in the Hamilton appeals in 2021) had other cases scheduled in the autumn, it was highly likely the full hearing would not be until 2027.

Edis did say he would ensure the court schedulers were aware of the importance of the case.

And that was that.

Another Compensation Development

As the hearing did not begin until 2pm I had the morning to write another blog post signposting the announcement of another element to the cursed Historical Shortfall Scheme.

The HSS was launched in 2020. In 2024, applicants were offered a fixed settlement sum of £75,000, no questions asked (providing, of course, they qualified for the scheme).

Unfortunately, the way this was done was unfair, exposed as unfair by various people and agreed as unfair by Sir Wyn Williams, who recommended that people who might have erroneously settled for £75,000, now get the chance to appeal it.

This recommendation was made in July last year. It took ten months to get round to making today’s announcement, and of course, the scheme isn’t actually open yet. Read all about it here. My thanks to Chris Head OBE for his insight and contribution to the piece.

Project Brisbane

Finally, another plug for the Project Brisbane investigation. I would really really really like to see what’s in that document. It might be a nothing burger, but it could be bigger than the Swift Review. Either way, I am deeply grateful to the indfatigable Eleanor Shaikh for doing so much of the running on this. Read all about it here.

Thanks so much for all the notes you have sent since I popped up last night. I am sorry I have not done so much on the Post Office recently. I am praying Sir Wyn schedules his final report to drop in June or July so a) we can all know who he thinks is to blame for this scandal and b) I can start shipping my book.

It’s embarrassing enough already, but I would hate to see publication put back to 2027. If you know Sir Wyn, tell him to pull his finger out. It’s tortuous.

Until next time – keep well.

Very best,

Nick

I will soon be publishing a new book about the Post Office scandal called The Great Post Office Cover-Up. You can put your money down now for a copy which will arrive after Sir Wyn Williams’ final report. Buying a pre-publication copy of the hardback (£15 + P&P) or paperback (£10 + P&P) will be cheaper than the post publication price, help support an independent publisher (by buying direct) and offer you the opportunity to join my secret email mailing list. For more info about the book, click here!


If you have been forwarded this newsletter and would like to get it delivered directly to your inbox when it is published, please consider making a donation to fund the journalism behind it. Anyone who donates any selected amount will be added to the secret email mailing list. This newsletter will keep you informed about developements at the Post Office Horizon IT inquiry and the wider scandal. Thanks.

www.PostOfficeScandal.uk

Newsletter Archives

  • ▼2026 (6)
  • ►2025 (14)
  • ►2024 (99)
  • ►2023 (52)
  • ►2022 (41)
  • ►2021 (68)
  • ►2020 (87)
  • ►2019 (142)
  • ►2018 (72)